All Male College, 1957

DavidXL

Legendary Member
Verified
Gold
Joined
Aug 30, 2009
Posts
777
Media
1
Likes
1,395
Points
423
Location
New York (United States)
Verification
View
Sexuality
80% Straight, 20% Gay
Gender
Male
Let me know what you think. How's the pace? Too much detail? Enough action?

All Male College, 1957

I had the terrible feeling I had made a disastrous mistake that was too late to fix. Now that I had arrived at Middlebury to start my freshman year of college, I felt a rising sense of panic that I should have gone to NYU instead of this small, preppy college in the mountains of rural Vermont. The thought of living amidst the grit and tumult of Greenwich Village had scared the suburban Connecticut 18 year old kid in me who had grown up surrounded by expansive green lawns and shady trees. Now, at this moment, the thought of living in the middle of nowhere with all of these college aged young men – and no co-eds – scared me even more.

I stood in the window in the second floor student lounge and looked down through the panes of glass at the curb below. My father opened the passenger door of the car for my mother. It was her ’55 Ford Country Squire station wagon, the model with the wood-paneling on the sides. The way-back was now empty. The books and clothes and winter jackets and starched sheets that had shared the ride with me were now neatly arranged in my dorm room upstairs. My mother hesitated for a moment as my father held the door for her and said something to him I obviously could not hear. Would they look up at the building and search for my face? Would they give me one last wave good-bye? How could they leave me here?

Only a few minutes ago, I just wanted them to hurry up and go with the hordes of other parents who had dropped off their sons and left without fanfare. I had been eager to rip off the bandage of their departure so that I could get on with the new life that awaited – and terrified – me. Now, at this moment, I wanted nothing more than to get back in the car with them and return to West Hartford, the place from where I had wanted to escape for as long as I could remember.

My mother checked her hair in a hand mirror she pulled out from her purse. My father flicked his cigarette butt on the sidewalk. He looked up at the sky as if he were a pilot about to climb aboard a plane and fly it away. He lit another cigarette and got in the car. They did not look up at me for one last wave or one last look at their only son. Instead, they sped off without looking back, and I was left only with the memory of our awkward farewell.

“Good luck, son,” my father had said as he had shaken my hand.
My mother had pressed an imaginary crease on the lapel of my blue blazer and straightened my tie. “Your father and I are very proud of you.”
“Yes, Mother.” I had responded with an ersatz formality I had summoned from deep inside, because I thought the situation and my parents were calling for it. The forced stoicism all seemed so ridiculous. The sad part of it is, I desperately wanted to be hugged and held by both of them, if even just briefly. I am a different kind of parent than mine were and would have hugged me tight if I had been them. But, back in 1957 when I was 18 and starting college, parents were afraid their sons would turn into fairies if they showed them too much affection.

The truth was, my biggest fear was that I just might be a fairy. That thought terrified me to my core, more than the fear that the Russians would drop an atom bomb and start a global thermonuclear war. Yes, I genuinely liked girls. I had even creamed in my pants as I finger-fucked Alison, my girlfriend, just last weekend. It had been in the back seat of the Ford Woody that had just whisked away my parents and my former life. Surely, that meant I wasn’t a fairy or a homosexual or a gay or a fruitcake or whatever people called people who shared some of the same feelings that people like me sometimes have, right?

It was also the truth that Alison had a diabolical way of stringing me along to the point of my extreme sexual frustration, but never giving me exactly what I wanted or needed when I wanted or needed it. For someone who was bored by baseball, she marked the boundaries of her sexual limits with bases, and it was pretty clear to me that she was protecting “home base” for as long as she could. The pattern was simple. First, we would kiss. Then, I would spend a few minutes rubbing my hand against the rigid wire undercarriage of her bra. She would pretend to resist by whispering me for me to stop while kissing me even harder.

After she dispensed with the faux resistance, she would let me go to second base. I would unhook her bra and release her large, but firm breasts. I would bury my face in them and savor the cool smoothness against my face. I would suck her nipples until they were hard and wet from my tongue. My cock throbbing like a hound at a tether, I would press against her and move my hand to reach under her dress.

Sometimes, she would reach down and give my boner a squeeze. The first time she had felt it, she had gasped. I had never seen a hard cock other than my own. But, I knew from my furtive knowledge of The Kinsey Report, that the 7 ½ inches I have is bigger than average and that I should be proud of the handful that I have going on. I would continue to press my rod against her while we kissed, each time hopeful there would be more. Then, invariably, she would stop me, and I knew she meant it. The passion would ebb from my body and brain. Soon my boner would subside, my balls still aching. I would drive her home, the silence laden with my sexual frustration.

This past weekend, however, she let me take matters further than she had all summer. She let me unbutton the top button of her jeans and let me slide my hand down through the top of her underwear. In the darkness, I slid my middle finger over the wetness while she moaned quietly. She did not put up any pretense of resistance or tell me to stop as I lingered on third. It felt so warm and wet and good. I was sure I was about to slide into home base.

“Maybe at Thanksgiving, if you still love me,” she had said. “We’re both going away to college, and we are both only 18.” I kissed her and continued to slide my finger over her wet slit and gently inside her. That was the most hope I had ever been offered of losing my virginity. My cock throbbed even harder in my khakis in a way that seemed to match my pulse. The more I kissed her and slid my finger over the slippery opening of her pussy, the more aroused I became. My hips moved back and forth in a slow grinding motion against her leg. Soon, I felt that all-too-familiar feeling and knew I was passing the point of no return.

There was no hope and no thought of stopping it. That churning, rushing, dizzy feeling came over me, and I was shooting burst after burst of warm semen into my underwear. I stifled a moan, because I was embarrassed at what was happening. I was afraid Alison would be repulsed and think I was a pervert. My breathing increased, but otherwise I did little to give away what happened. My cock was a pulsing, gooey mess, and I hoped the mess wouldn’t leak through my pants. In the darkness, there was no way to tell. I didn’t care. It felt too good.

I pulled up in front of Alison’s house, which was dark. We kissed again, and she said how close she felt to me. I said I felt the same way. I held her hand as we walked up the pathway to her door in the darkness and made plans to see each other at Thanksgiving. Just before we reached the porch steps, the lights at the front of the house suddenly snapped on and blazed the steps with blinding brightness.

In an instant, the front door opened, and there was Alison’s father. He smiled disingenuously. He was always polite to me, but not-so-deep down, I know he despised me. In his mind, I was not the responsible college boy next door with the bright future. I was just some guy who wanted to fuck his daughter. He had just started to ask how our evening was when he stopped mid-sentence. He had caught sight of the shameful semen stain that was now the size of a slice of baloney across the crotch of my rumpled khakis. My stomach lurched in fear and I placed my hand on the wet stain. But it was too late, and the stain was too big to hide.

His eyes narrowed to slits. “Good night, Jack. Good luck at Dartmouth.” He pulled Alison inside and slammed the door shut.

“Actually, it’s Middlebury,” I muttered to myself as I walked back to my car, wondering how I could ever face either of them again.

I was really horny for Alison and desperately craved for more than she was giving me. But, my other undeniable truth was that I also liked men. It scared and confused me to think that as much as I ached to distraction for pussy, I also had the “devious homosexual tendencies” you would sometimes read about in psychology text books or in newspaper articles about police raids of bars that catered to the homosexual. If I was your normal, clean cut, wholesome boy next door, why did I sometimes have the abnormal, deviant desire to look at and maybe even touch a guy’s cock, preferably a big one? It had never happened yet. But, as I looked at all of these undeniably good looking guys who would be my classmates for the next 4 years, could I trust myself to keep those thoughts safely to myself?
 
Last edited:
Thanks, everyone, for reading and for the feedback. Here's the next chapter. Again, please let me know if you have any comments about pace, subject matter, detail, etc.

Chapter 2: My First Glimpse of Dusty and the Gang Shower (M/M)

I wasn’t sure what to do with myself. It seemed already that some of the guys had met other guys in the dorm and had become fast friends, even though none of us had been here for more than an hour or two. My parents had been gone only minutes, and I hadn’t met anyone yet. I was acutely conscious of being . . . alone. Back in West Hartford, I had a wide circle of friends I had known my entire life. I had never lived anywhere else and had grown up with the same people to the point that the familiarity that enveloped me had become stifling. That was a big reason why I had been so eager to leave. Another reason was that I had the feeling that bigger things in life were meant for me outside of Central Connecticut, and I couldn’t start living the rest of my life until I left and started living it. Now that I was getting what I wished for, however, I couldn’t help but wonder if what I had back home wasn’t so bad after all.

I tried to shake the negative thoughts from my head. I knew I had to. I realized that my life from this moment forward was at a new starting block and I needed to steel myself for the challenge. Otherwise, I would be left behind. I took a deep breath.

I went back up to my floor and stopped in to take a leak in the bathroom at the end of the hall. Inside, the walls were covered with the wide glazed brick tiles that were a “hospital green” color you don’t see much anymore except in old institutional buildings. Even at my age, my cock stirs at the memory whenever I am in an older building and see that same tile. There was a row of sinks against one wall, a row of urinals against another, a row of stalls against the other and an opening off in the corner that lead to the shower room with which I would later become well-familiar. You couldn’t fully see into the showers unless you stuck your head inside, but it was a rectangular room with 8 shower heads. It was a gang shower, of course, with no curtains. There never were back then. I thought abstractly that that was where I would be showering with my floor mates. I had the fleeting image of what the shower room would look like when all of the shower heads were in use and spraying water everywhere over the nude bodies of the young men I had not yet met. I shook my head. “Stop it,” I thought and dispatched that image.

I could hear the sound of one shower head in use. It struck me as an odd time to be taking a shower, since most of the other freshmen were still arriving and there were still parents on the floor. But, I didn’t pay it much attention, and the thought left my head.

I unzipped my pants and pulled my cock out at the urinal and started to go. I hadn’t gone since right before breakfast at the inn with my parents, several hours ago. Until now, I hadn’t realized how badly I had to go. I closed my eyes and savored the delicious sense of relief as my bladder drained in a strong, steady stream. After a few moments, I looked down to enjoy the relaxed, elongated look of my cock as I peed. While I waited to finish, I gently rubbed my thumb across the thick vein that ran along the length of the topside of my cock. I have since received many comments not just about that vein, but my cock in general. I know it must sound kind of weird, and apologies for the immodesty, but I know I have a big, good-looking cock, and I like to look at it in every form. Hard. Soft. In-between. Like every 18 year old, it was an endless source of fascination that I had spent hours exploring.

Finally, I finished. I shook my cock dry and was careful to splatter the remaining drops of piss in the urinal instead of on the front of my khakis. I sighed audibly and was relieved to be relieved. At just about the same time I flushed, I could hear the shower turn off. I couldn’t see who was inside the shower room, but I wondered who would be emerging and whether I might get to see his cock. “Stop it,” I told myself again. “Stop it.”

As I was at the sink washing my hands, I heard a friendly, “Hello.”

I turned around to see who had said it. The word “Hello” was on my lips, but it lingered there for a beat or two as I took in the sight before me. I caught myself and said, “Hello” again, forcefully this time, in case I had swallowed the word the first time and not been properly heard.

“The name’s Dusty McCaffrey,” he said.

It was almost overwhelming to behold the sight in front of me. Dusty was nude, unabashedly and unprovocatively toweling himself off at the entrance of the shower room. About twenty years later, a motion picture called “The Blue Lagoon” would be released starring an actor named Christopher Atkins who bore an uncanny resemblance to Dusty, except in my recollections, Dusty was hotter. Dusty was about 6’1” with a lean, cut, v-shaped torso. He had ringlets of curly hair that were multiple shades of blond naturally bleached by summers in the sun. His hair was by no means long by today’s standards, but long for the times back then in 1957 and not what you would often see in New England. His eyes were the deepest, warmest cerulean blue. It was hard not to be swallowed up by them and forget what you were saying. It was not just his looks, however, that made him so compelling. There was something more. There was an aura about him that transcends looks. It’s hard to pinpoint exactly what it was. His smile? The warmth in his eyes? The intensity and curiosity in the way he carried himself and interacted with others? His uncommon decency? Whatever it was, the whole package was something you almost never encountered in one person.

“Hi, Dusty. Jack Benson,” I said. “Nice to meet you.”

“You’re from West Hartford,” he said. My face asked “How could you know that?” before my mouth could. “I’m the resident advisor,” he said. “I recognized your name from my list. I’m a senior and live on the floor. I’m here to help keep order on the floor,” he said with a knowing smirk. “But, also to help out if you ever have any problems with anything or just need someone to talk to.”

“Great,” I said. Great was right. Dusty was one of the most incredibly handsome young men I had ever seen before. I couldn’t believe how casual he was about being nude, especially in front of me. In the starkest of contrasts, I was still dressed in my khakis, with a blue blazer, buttoned-down shirt, and repp tie. Dusty’s naked body was mostly smooth, except for a dark brown treasure trail that bisected his abs and lead south in the direction I most wanted to take my eyes, but didn’t yet dare. When you are what I am, you are careful to look at what your body aches for you to look at without being noticed. You develop excellent peripheral vision. You go undercover and collect stolen glances. But, even all that never fully satisfied the hunger that those who are like me know of.

“Where are you from?” I asked. He started to towel those curly blond locks. I had my moment and seized it as he covered his scalp. Good Lord! His cock was long and thick and spongy. It was just as beautiful as he was, if not more so. It bounced with confidence from side-to-side as he dried his hair. He was clip-dicked with a broad brown band around the middle of it that suggested to me that while he certainly wasn’t hard, he wasn’t completely soft either. It made me wonder what had gone on in the shower while I had been taking a leak. Or whether this was all for my benefit. The head was a smooth, shiny helmet that was perfectly proportioned with the rest of his cock. If I had to wager a guess, I’d say he was definitely about 5 inches long at that moment and would have had to have been at least 7 to 8 inches hard. The memory of that first sighting of his nude body and truly glorious cock is seared into my memory. I have never forgotten it after all of these years, and it will be with me until I take my last breath.

“Where am I from? Orange County, California,” he said. “My family grows oranges.” It’s hard to believe it now, but back then, Orange County was mostly agricultural. It was mile after mile of nothing but orange groves and people like Dusty’s family growing them. “I’m sunkissed,” he said.

“That explains the nice tan you have going on there.”

He smiled that smile of his, the one that pulls you in and doesn’t ever let you out. “Hey, thanks,” he said, patting the well-defined line that marked the golden hue of his flat, tanned belly with the stark whiteness of his thighs and pubic region. Because he patted that non-imaginary line, I granted myself the right to take another look at what my mind ached for my eyes to devour and took a longer look at that jiggling pendulum between his legs.

“My family has a bungalow, for weekends and vacations, in this little town called Laguna Beach. Have you ever heard of it?’

I shook my head, no. My mouth was dry. I licked my lips, not with desire, but because I was afraid I might not be able to speak otherwise.

“Not many people have,” he continued. “I get down there every chance I get when I’m not helping out on our orange grove. I love it in Laguna. It’s small and peaceful and quiet. At night, in bed, you can hear the crash of the waves. I surf all summer. It’s my favorite place on earth.”

My eyes met his. His smile was warm, not leering. He had moved close enough to shake hands, but not close enough to suggest any kind of an invitation. “It’s real nice to meet you,” I said.

“Same to you,” he said. I grabbed another quick glance at his glorious cock. Suddenly, the door to the bathroom opened, and Dusty took that instant to wrap his towel around his waist and remind me to show up for dorm orientation in the second floor lounge later that afternoon.

“You remind me of somebody,” he said as he turned to leave. “I’m just not sure who.”

“I get that a lot,” I said. And it was the truth. I was not a matinee idol, but I knew my dark-haired good looks, shy smile, and the brown eyes that opened up to the depth of my soul had their appeal to people who wanted what I had. I almost always reminded someone of someone else, they could just not remember who. It’s as if there was a familiarity about me. I guess there are worse things to say about someone, and I always took it as a compliment.

He nodded and smiled at the same time. And then he was gone.

As luck would have it, that was the first, but certainly not the last time I saw his cock. I can still see it in my mind as I type these words. I later asked Dusty if he had known what he was doing to me at that moment. He had laughed and said he hadn’t known for certain, but he had been damn sure he had wanted to make a good impression. I didn’t know it yet, but I had just met one of the most extraordinary people, both inside and outside, that I would ever meet in my whole life. Years later, when I was watching that silly, little movie, “The Blue Lagoon,” I would break down weeping in the middle of it and have to leave the theater at the memory of Dusty. But, that was years later. Back at that first meeting, I was thinking only for the short term that this impossibly handsome older brother type of guy was someone I wanted to get to know better.
 
Absolutely one of the best reads on this site and definitely publishing worthy.
Please, by all means continue, and even more, give Jack and Dusty a complete story.

Congrats and thanks for submitting your work.
 
  • Like
Reactions: deleted6071181