An Unlikely Complicated Reunion

Chris Mobley

Expert Member
Joined
Sep 30, 2017
Posts
36
Media
0
Likes
118
Points
68
Location
Alabama, United States)
Sexuality
100% Gay, 0% Straight
Gender
Male
Nathan DeLuca stood at the stove of his bustling restaurant, "Harvest Table," where the scent of garlic, fresh herbs, and sizzling butter filled the air. His knife skills were surgical, his commands sharp but fair, and his focus unyielding. As the owner and head chef, Nathan’s precision and passion had turned the restaurant into the most sought-after dining spot in town. Every night was a full house, the kitchen humming with activity. Nathan thrived here, in his world of flavors and fire.

Outside the chaos of the kitchen, Nathan’s life was simpler. He lived alone in a modest apartment with his cat, Scooter. Relationships had never been a priority—his one true love had always been cooking.

Everything changed on a quiet Tuesday evening when Ethan Bradford stepped through the doors of "Harvest Table."

Ethan Bradford didn’t need a reservation, but he’d made one anyway. His wealth and connections could have secured him the best table in any restaurant, but Ethan preferred to blend in. As he walked in, the hostess greeted him with a polished smile.

“Welcome to Harvest Table, Mr. Bradford. Your table is ready.”

Ethan followed her to a small, discreet table with a clear view of the open kitchen. His sharp suit and confident stride turned heads, but he only had eyes for the man commanding the kitchen—a man he thought he knew.

Nathan was focused, his dark hair damp with sweat, his hands moving with practiced ease. Ethan’s heart raced as memories flooded back: years ago, he had met someone who looked just like Nathan. The connection had been brief but profound, a fleeting encounter that had stayed with him ever since. Could this really be the same man?

Ethan lingered over his meal, savoring not only the exquisite dishes but also the sight of Nathan at work. After finishing, he left a note with the hostess.

The food was exceptional. I’d love to catch up sometime. —E.B.

The next morning, Nathan found the note among the receipts. He frowned, not recognizing the initials. "Who’s E.B.?" he muttered to his sous chef, Angela.

“The guy at table eight last night,” she replied with a shrug. “Looked like he walked out of a magazine. He asked about you.”

Nathan rolled his eyes and tossed the note aside. It wasn’t the first time a customer had shown interest in him, but he didn’t have time for distractions. Still, something about the message nagged at him throughout the day.

Two days later, Ethan returned. This time, he asked to speak with Nathan directly. The staff exchanged curious glances, and Angela finally convinced Nathan to step out.

Nathan approached the table, wiping his hands on his apron. “You wanted to see me?”

Ethan stood and extended a hand. “Nathan, it’s Ethan Bradford. I think we met years ago. At a food festival in Napa?”



Nathan blinked, confused. “I’ve never been to Napa.”

Ethan’s confident smile faltered. “Are you sure? I could’ve sworn—”

“Pretty sure I’d remember,” Nathan said flatly. “Enjoy your meal.” He turned and walked back to the kitchen, leaving Ethan sitting there, stunned.

Despite the awkward encounter, Ethan couldn’t shake the feeling that Nathan was the same man from Napa. He returned to "Harvest Table" weekly, always requesting a table with a view of the kitchen. Though Nathan remained distant, Ethan’s persistence slowly chipped away at the chef’s icy demeanor.

One evening, Ethan lingered at the bar after closing. Nathan, exhausted but curious, finally approached him. “You’re still here?”

“I didn’t want to leave without apologizing,” Ethan said. “I might’ve mistaken you for someone else, but I’d still like to get to know you.”

Nathan crossed his arms. “Why? What’s so interesting about me?”

Ethan hesitated, then said, “Because you’re real. Everything about you—your passion, your focus—it’s rare. I admire that.”

Nathan studied him for a moment. “Flattery doesn’t work on me.”

“Good,” Ethan said with a grin. “I’m not trying to flatter you. I’m just being honest.”

Over the next few months, Ethan’s visits became a routine. He never pushed too hard, always respecting Nathan’s boundaries. Instead, he found small ways to support him—sending rare ingredients to the restaurant, leaving thoughtful notes about the dishes, and even befriending the staff.

Angela teased Nathan mercilessly. “You know he’s got it bad for you, right?”

Nathan shook his head. “He’s just persistent. He’ll get bored eventually.”

But Ethan didn’t get bored. One night, after closing, Nathan found himself sharing a bottle of wine with Ethan in the quiet dining room. For the first time, he let his guard down.

“Why do you keep coming back?” Nathan asked.

Ethan swirled his wine thoughtfully. “Because the more I get to know you, the more I realize how wrong I was. You’re not the man I thought I met years ago. You’re better.”

Nathan’s cheeks flushed, and he looked away. “You don’t know me.”

“Then let me,” Ethan said softly.

Their relationship developed gradually, built on late-night conversations, shared meals, and moments of unexpected vulnerability. Ethan revealed the pressures of growing up in a wealthy family, always feeling like he had to prove his worth. Nathan shared stories of his struggles to build "Harvest Table" from the ground up, sacrificing everything for his dream.

One night, Ethan surprised Nathan by volunteering in the kitchen during a charity event. Though his knife skills left much to be desired, his effort didn’t go unnoticed.



“You’re terrible at this,” Nathan said with a laugh as he watched Ethan attempt to dice an onion.

“But I’m learning,” Ethan replied, grinning. “And I’ll keep learning if it means spending more time with you.”

Nathan shook his head, but he couldn’t hide his smile. “You’re ridiculous.”

“And you like it,” Ethan teased.

As the months turned into seasons, Nathan found himself facing an undeniable truth: he was looking forward to Ethan’s visits. What had started as an irritating misunderstanding was evolving into a connection he hadn’t anticipated. The once-cold exterior Nathan maintained was beginning to thaw, much to the amusement of his staff.

Ethan, for his part, had proven he wasn’t just a wealthy man with a fleeting interest. He became a familiar face at "Harvest Table," not just as a customer but as someone who truly appreciated Nathan’s craft. He supported the restaurant in small, thoughtful ways—introducing Nathan to local farmers with unique produce, recommending the restaurant to influential friends, and even helping organize a fundraiser for culinary scholarships in Nathan’s name.

One evening, after a particularly busy service, Nathan arrived home to find Ethan waiting in the hallway outside his apartment door, holding a bag of groceries and a mischievous grin. "Thought I’d try cooking for a change," Ethan said.

Nathan raised an eyebrow. "You? Cooking? This I have to see."


Inside Nathan’s modest apartment, Scooter meowed lazily from his perch on the windowsill as Ethan unpacked the groceries. "I’m not promising anything fancy," Ethan said, his sleeves rolled up as he inspected a package of pasta. "But I figured I could try making something simple."

Nathan leaned against the counter, arms crossed, amused. "Pasta is safe. Less room for disaster."

Ethan laughed. "That’s the spirit." He paused, looking at Nathan. "You could help, you know."

"I do enough cooking," Nathan shot back, but he stepped forward anyway. "What’s the plan?"

The evening turned into a chaotic mix of laughter, spilled sauce, and Ethan’s exaggerated frustration when the pasta stuck together. Nathan couldn’t remember the last time he’d laughed so freely. Despite the less-than-perfect meal, they sat down at the small kitchen table and shared it together.

"This is terrible," Nathan teased, taking a bite.

Ethan grinned. "Hey, I never claimed to be a chef."


As their evenings together became more frequent, Nathan started to see past Ethan’s polished exterior. Over time, Ethan shared stories of his upbringing—how his family’s wealth had often made him feel isolated, and how he had spent years trying to carve out a sense of purpose beyond their expectations.

"You don’t strike me as someone who struggles with purpose," Nathan said one night as they sat on the couch, Scooter sprawled across Ethan’s lap.

Ethan ran a hand through his hair, his expression contemplative. "It’s easy to look like you have it all together when you have money. But it doesn’t mean you’re happy. I spent years trying to figure out who I was outside of my last name."

Nathan nodded, understanding more than he expected. "I get it. Building this restaurant—it’s the only thing I’ve ever wanted. It cost me relationships, time with my family... Sometimes I wonder if it’s worth it."

Ethan met his gaze. "It is. You’ve created something amazing, Nathan. And I think it’s part of why I—" He hesitated, then smiled softly. "Why I keep coming back."


But life wasn’t as simple as romantic dinners and heartfelt conversations. Nathan struggled with the idea of letting someone into his world. He had spent so long focusing on his career that the idea of a relationship felt foreign and, at times, overwhelming.

Meanwhile, Ethan found himself battling his own insecurities. Though he tried to give Nathan space, his feelings for the chef grew stronger with every interaction. He worried that his persistence might push Nathan away.

The breaking point came one evening when Ethan surprised Nathan with an elaborate gift: a custom-built smoker for the restaurant. Though it was thoughtful, Nathan bristled at the gesture.

"You can’t just throw money at everything," Nathan said, his tone sharper than he intended.

Ethan stepped back, startled. "I wasn’t trying to... I just wanted to do something meaningful for you."

"Meaningful doesn’t have to cost a fortune," Nathan snapped, then sighed, running a hand through his hair. "Look, I appreciate it. I do. But you don’t have to prove anything to me."

Ethan nodded, his expression subdued. "I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to overstep."


The tension lingered for a few days, but eventually, they talked it through. Nathan admitted that his reaction had more to do with his own fears than Ethan’s actions. "I’m not used to this," he confessed. "Letting someone in. Depending on someone."

Ethan smiled gently. "Then let’s take it one step at a time. No pressure. Just us."

From that point on, they focused on finding a balance—one that allowed Nathan to maintain his independence while letting Ethan show his love in ways that felt genuine. They spent more time outside of the restaurant, exploring the city, trying new foods, and even taking a weekend trip to the countryside.

One evening, as they walked along the river after dinner, Nathan stopped suddenly. The city lights reflected on the water, casting a warm glow over their surroundings. He turned to Ethan, his expression uncharacteristically vulnerable.

"I never thought I’d say this," Nathan began, his voice steady but soft, "but you’ve made me realize there’s more to life than the restaurant."

Ethan’s heart swelled as he reached for Nathan’s hand. "And you’ve made me realize there’s more to love than just finding the right person. It’s about timing, trust, and... patience."

Nathan smirked. "Patience, huh? Must’ve taken a lot of that to deal with me."

Ethan laughed. "More than you know. But it was worth it."

As they stood there, hand in hand, Nathan finally allowed himself to believe that love didn’t have to be complicated. It could be simple, real, and exactly what he needed to complement the life he had built so carefully. For the first time, he felt ready to share that life with someone else.


Just when Nathan and Ethan’s relationship seemed to find its rhythm, the unexpected happened. A few weeks after their quiet revelation, Ethan walked into "Harvest Table" with an uneasy look on his face. At his side stood a man who looked vaguely familiar to Nathan.

"Nathan, this is... um, this is Leo," Ethan said, hesitating slightly. "Leo is... someone I knew a long time ago."

Nathan raised an eyebrow. "Knew?"

Leo extended a hand, his warm smile disarming. "We went to school together," he explained. "Ethan and I were close back then. Really close."

Ethan’s face turned slightly red. "Leo reached out recently, and... well, I thought it would be nice for him to visit the restaurant."

Nathan forced a polite smile, shaking Leo’s hand. "Welcome to Harvest Table. Enjoy the food."

Ethan looked relieved that Nathan wasn’t overtly hostile, but Nathan couldn’t ignore the pang of irritation growing in his chest. Something about Leo’s presence felt off.


That evening, after the restaurant closed, Nathan cornered Ethan as they cleaned up. "So, what’s the deal with Leo?"

Ethan sighed, leaning against the counter. "I thought he was you."

Nathan blinked, stunned. "What?"
 
"When I first walked into your restaurant months ago, I thought you were Leo," Ethan admitted. "He and I had this... intense connection back in school, but we lost touch. When I saw you, I thought I’d found him again. That’s why I kept coming back."

Nathan stared at Ethan, his expression unreadable. "So all this time, you were chasing a ghost?"

"At first, yes," Ethan said quickly. "But that’s not what this is anymore. Somewhere along the way, I stopped seeing Leo in you and started seeing you for who you are."

Nathan crossed his arms, his voice colder than he intended. "And now Leo’s back."

Ethan frowned. "It’s not like that."

"Isn’t it?" Nathan snapped. "You spent months thinking I was someone else. And now the real someone else is here."

Ethan hesitated, unsure how to respond. "I don’t know what you want me to say."

"I want the truth," Nathan said, his voice firm. "Do you still have feelings for him?"


Over the next few weeks, the dynamic between the three men grew increasingly complicated. Ethan found himself torn between his unresolved feelings for Leo and his growing love for Nathan. Leo, sensing the tension, began to push for more time with Ethan, subtly reminding him of their shared history.

One evening, Leo invited Ethan to dinner at a quiet bistro. As they talked, Ethan couldn’t help but feel the pull of nostalgia. Leo was charming, funny, and effortlessly charismatic—everything Ethan had once fallen for. But something was missing. As much as Ethan enjoyed Leo’s company, his mind kept drifting to Nathan: his stubborn determination, his passion for cooking, and the way his eyes softened when he let his guard down.

Later that night, Ethan returned to Nathan’s apartment, his thoughts a whirlwind. Nathan was sitting on the couch, Scooter curled up beside him. He looked up as Ethan entered, his expression guarded.

"How was dinner?" Nathan asked, his tone neutral.

Ethan sat down across from him, running a hand through his hair. "Complicated."

Nathan nodded, looking away. "I figured as much."

"Nathan," Ethan said softly, leaning forward. "I need you to know something."

Nathan met his gaze, waiting.

"Leo was my past," Ethan said firmly. "And yes, seeing him again brought back a lot of memories. But that’s all they are—memories. My future, the person I want to build something real with, is you."

Nathan studied him for a long moment before speaking. "You sure about that? Because I’m not interested in being anyone’s second choice."

Ethan reached out, taking Nathan’s hand. "You’re not my second choice. You’re my only choice."

Though Nathan was hesitant, he decided to give Ethan the benefit of the doubt. Over time, Ethan distanced himself from Leo, making it clear where his heart truly lay. Leo, recognizing the depth of Ethan’s feelings for Nathan, gracefully bowed out, wishing them well.

Or so it seemed.

As weeks passed, Ethan found himself increasingly distracted by thoughts of Leo. Though his relationship with Nathan continued to deepen, a part of him couldn’t shake the lingering "what if?" of his past with Leo. Things took an unexpected turn when Leo texted Ethan late one night.

"Can we meet? Just to talk."

Ethan hesitated, staring at the message. He told himself it would be harmless—just closure. But as they sat across from each other at a cozy café the next evening, closure seemed far from Leo’s mind.

"I know I said I was bowing out," Leo began, his voice low and earnest. "But I can’t stop thinking about you. About us."

Ethan’s heart raced. "Leo... I’m with Nathan now."

"I know," Leo said, leaning closer. "But do you love him the way you loved me?"

The question lingered, heavy and unanswerable.


As if Ethan’s life wasn’t complicated enough, a chance encounter added another layer of confusion. While walking through the city one afternoon, he bumped into Eric, an old college flame. Eric, with his rugged charm and easy smile, had been Ethan’s first real love—the one who got away.

"Ethan?" Eric said, his eyes lighting up. "Wow, it’s been years."

They spent hours catching up, and Ethan couldn’t deny the spark that still flickered between them. Eric’s reappearance threw Ethan into a tailspin. Now he wasn’t just torn between Leo and Nathan—Eric was back in the picture, complicating everything further.

Ethan’s days became a blur of indecision. He tried to focus on his relationship with Nathan, but his mind kept drifting to Leo’s lingering passion and Eric’s unexpected return. Each man represented a different piece of his life: Nathan was stability, Leo was nostalgia, and Eric was the thrill of what could have been.

Nathan, sensing Ethan’s distraction, confronted him one evening. "You’ve been distant," he said, his voice tinged with frustration. "What’s going on?"

Ethan hesitated, torn between honesty and fear. "I’m trying to figure things out," he admitted. "It’s... complicated."

Nathan’s expression hardened. "Complicated? Or are you just keeping your options open?"

The words stung, but Ethan knew they weren’t entirely untrue. He had to make a choice—one that would inevitably hurt someone he cared about.


One rainy evening, Ethan found himself alone in his apartment, staring at three letters he had written—one for Nathan, one for Leo, and one for Eric. Each letter represented a different path, a different future.

As the rain pelted against the window, Ethan picked up the letter addressed to Nathan. He knew where his heart truly belonged. It wasn’t about the past or the what-ifs—it was about the person who had been there, steady and unwavering, even when things got complicated.

The next morning, Ethan walked into "Harvest Table," the letter clutched in his hand. Nathan looked up from the kitchen, surprise flashing across his face.

"Ethan?"

Ethan stepped closer, his heart pounding. "I choose you, Nathan. It’s always been you."



Nathan stood in his restaurant's kitchen, the rhythm of pots and pans clattering around him providing a familiar sense of purpose. Cooking was his passion and his escape, and lately, he needed an escape more than ever. The chaos of his personal life had become unbearable. Ethan, Leo, and Eric had all entered his world in a whirlwind, each leaving him utterly confused about what he wanted—or who he wanted.

He leaned over the stove, tasting the sauce bubbling in a saucepan, when the door to the kitchen swung open. Eric walked in, looking unusually nervous. "Nathan, we need to talk."

Nathan didn’t look up, focusing on his dish. "Make it quick. I have a dining room full of people waiting on this meal."

Eric hesitated before stepping closer. "It’s about Ethan and Leo."

Nathan froze, his grip tightening on the wooden spoon. "What about them?"

Eric exhaled slowly. "Leo’s... not who he seems. And I think you should know, he’s been saying things about you and Ethan."

Nathan turned to face him, his expression unreadable. "Why do you care? I thought you were done with all of this."

Eric ran a hand through his hair. "Because I care about you, Nathan. More than I should, maybe. And I don’t want to see you get hurt."

Nathan’s brow furrowed, his chest tightening. "Eric, I don’t even know what I feel right now. About you, about Ethan, about any of this."

Eric stepped closer, his voice soft but insistent. "Then let me help you figure it out."


Later that evening, after closing the restaurant, Nathan reluctantly agreed to join Eric and Leo for drinks. Ethan had declined the invitation, claiming he needed time alone. The atmosphere at the bar was tense, with Nathan caught in the middle of two men vying for his attention.

Leo leaned in close, his voice smooth and persuasive. "Nathan, I know this has been overwhelming for you, but you have to see how good we’d be together."

Nathan gave him a sidelong glance. "Leo, I don’t even know what you want from me."

Leo smirked, sliding a drink toward Nathan. "I just want you to be happy."

Eric, who had been silently fuming, finally spoke up. "That’s rich coming from you, Leo. You’re just trying to manipulate me."

Leo’s eyes narrowed. "Jealousy doesn’t suit you, Eric."

Nathan sighed, rubbing his temples. "Can we not do this right now?"

As the night wore on, Nathan began to feel strangely lightheaded. He shook his head, trying to clear the fog. "I think I need to go home," he muttered.

Eric quickly offered to help him. "I’ll get you there safely. Come on."

Nathan nodded, leaning heavily on Eric as they left the bar. The next thing he remembered was waking up in an unfamiliar bed, his head pounding. He sat up abruptly, realizing he wasn’t alone.

Eric was sitting on the edge of the bed, looking guilty. "Nathan, I swear, nothing happened. You weren’t feeling well, so I brought you here."

Nathan stared at him, his confusion turning to anger. "Why didn’t you just take me home?"

Before Eric could answer, the door burst open, and Leo stormed in. His eyes widened as he took in the scene. "Well, isn’t this cozy?"

Nathan groaned, running a hand through his hair. "This is not what it looks like."

Leo crossed his arms, a smug smile playing on his lips. "Does Ethan know about your little sleepover?"

Nathan’s stomach sank. "Leo, don’t do this."

Leo shrugged. "I won’t—if you give me what I want."

The tension between the four of them reached a breaking point. Ethan confronted Nathan the next day, his voice trembling with emotion. "Why didn’t you tell me about what happened with Eric?"

Nathan looked away, guilt etched on his face. "Because nothing happened. At least, not the way Leo is making it seem."

Ethan shook his head. "I don’t know if I can believe that."

Nathan’s frustration boiled over. "You’re one to talk, Ethan. You’ve been stringing all of us along for weeks."

Ethan’s eyes flashed with anger. "I didn’t ask for any of this! I didn’t ask to feel this way about you, or Leo, or Eric."

Before Nathan could respond, Eric walked in, his expression grim. "Enough. This isn’t helping anyone."

Nathan turned to him, his voice sharp. "Then what do you suggest, Eric? Because I’m out of ideas."

Eric hesitated before speaking. "Maybe it’s time we all took a step back. Figure out what we really want before we tear each other apart."
 
As Nathan was cooking in the kitchen he started to remember things. Remembering Eric taking him to his place. Undressing him and having sex with him. Not just one time but 4 times during the night. At first, he used a condom and then he decided he wanted to make Nathan his so he dissed the condom and started raw dogging Nathan. Nathan was a bit groggy and was struggling a bit so Eric got some towels and tied Nathan to the bed face down. He put 2 pillows under his belly to raise his ass into the air. At this point, Nathan felt himself feeling sick. He could feel everything as if it was just now happening. Then Eric started eating Nathan’s ass. Shoving his tongue deep inside him. He could taste the residue of latex left behind by the condom he had used the first time he fucked Nathan so he stopped and lubed up his raw dick and rammed it inside Nathan who couldn’t resist or say no. He fucked Nathan so hard that his head started hitting the wall at the top of the bed. So Eric put a few pillows at the top of the bed to prevent Nathan from hitting his head. Now he went back to eating Nathan's ass as he could now taste his precum inside Nathan. This made him so hard, so he started fucking Nathan again and soon busted a huge nut inside his ass. Then he went back to Nathan's ass to felch out his own cum. He so enjoyed the taste of his sweet milk as he dined on Nathan’s ass like it was a gourmet meal. Nathan was motionless at this point so again Eric mounted his ass and fucked him a few more times and each time he would eat his own cum from Nathan’s ass. The memories of the events led Nathan to the bathroom where he started puking recalling the details of how Eric had raped him that night. He had bred him multiple times. At the same time, he couldn’t help but get turned on thinking someone wanted him so bad they would go so far as to spike his drink just to do that. The conflict of what had occurred left Nathan so messed up and confused. He wondered how he could be turned on by someone raping him. Cumming inside him and then eating it back out multiple times. His kinky side was getting the better of him and he found himself with a raging hard-on, so he locked the door to the bathroom, took off his pants, and spit in his hands to jack himself off while thinking about what had been done to him. As he stood there after nutting, his hand still full of his warm cum, he wondered what it was like for Eric to eat his cum out of Nathan’s ass, so Nathan proceeded to eat the cum from his own hand. In the moment he was so turned on by the taste of his own cum. It was something he had never done before and never even thought about doing. The Night to Forget was something he truly would never forget because it was one of the best and worst sexual experiences he had ever had before. Nathan put his pants back on and went to the sink to wash his hands and opened the medicine cabinet where he kept a spare toothbrush. He didn’t want to be caught with puke breath, so he thoroughly brushed his teeth and tongue. He walked back into the busy kitchen full of busy cooks. As he walked towards the station he had been working at he noticed a glob of cum on his pants. What should he do now? He was right in the middle of his kitchen, so he took his hand quickly swiped the cum from his pants, and shoved it in his mouth. He took a step forward while wallowing the glob of cum around in his mouth. Enjoying the taste that reminded him of all that had happened. Suddenly a tap on his shoulder. He turned to find Ethan standing right there. He leaned in very quickly and gave him a really deep passionate kiss.

“What have you been eating?” Ethan said.

“Oh, just tasting one of the desserts I’ve been experimenting with for the new menu I’m working on,” Nathan responded, not sure what else he could say because he had only the glob of cum in his mouth after having just brushed his teeth.

“Well, it’s really sweet, maybe add a little more spice to cut the sugary sweetness.” He replied

OMG did he really just tell me how sweet my cum was.

“I just wanted to stop in and let you know I have to go out of town for a week on some personal business” Ethan replied, and at that, he left the kitchen.

The next day I called up Eric, “Hey, I think we need to talk about something” I told Eric. “When is a good time for you?’

“Is something wrong?” Eric quickly replied.

“Not really, just need to talk about something with you. I’m not working tomorrow night. Can you come over and maybe have dinner?” I suggested.

Eric nervously agreed.

The rest of that night I pondered over what I would fix for dinner. I wanted to put him through the wringer before I told him I had remembered what happened.

Just then another tap on my shoulder and I turn to find Leo.

“Chris we need to talk”, Leo proclaimed with a defiant voice

“What’s to talk about? You want to blackmail me for something that never happened.” I confidently said.

“After you get off we will talk, understand that. I caught you red-handed and if you don’t follow through with giving me what I want then I’m gonna let the cat out of the bag and let Ethan know everything that you two did.” Retorted Leo.

“OK, give me 15 minutes and we can go somewhere to speak privately,” I said rather annoyed.



So, I took him back to my place where we could speak privately.

“Leo, what exactly do you want from me” I demanded.

“Well I want the same thing that you gave Eric,” Leo said with a very confident tone.

“I already told you that nothing happened. I had gotten sick and passed out that night and Eric took me back to his place where you found us.” I responded angrily.

“I want you for one night, just give me one night. I know the smell of old cum and the room was full of that smell when I found you both.” He demandingly responded back.

“So let’s be clear, you want to fuck me, is that what you want?” I said with an unwavering tone.

He nodded in the affirmative and then started undressing right in front of me and motioned for me to do the same.

“I didn’t agree to your demands.” I replied back to which he just said, “Take off your clothes. Or I call Ethan right now.”

I watched Leo as slowly removed his clothes and he reached over and started undressing me himself. He stood there in just his underwear. They were bikini briefs with bright pink hearts on them and a huge bulge in the front that seemed to be staring me down. As he pulled my pants and underwear down and looked up at me and said, “You’ve recently masturbated, I can tell and taste” as he licked the tip of my dick. There was still a bit of dried-up cum underneath the head of my dick. He started sucking me like a hungry animal. Then he picked me up and carried me to my room and threw me onto my bed face down and buried his face in my ass. His tongue was so warm I was having flashbacks of Eric doing the same to me. It was as if Leo was copying Eric. It felt so good and so wrong at the same time. Leo flipped me onto my back and climbed on top of me and shoved his dick in my mouth. His wasn’t what I expected. He had a thick veiny uncut cock. I have never sucked an uncut cock before. It was quite different. There was so much foreskin. I reach up with my hand to pull his skin back. That’s when he busted in my mouth. So warm and creamy. His cum was very thick and a bit tangy. “Swallow it all.” Leo demanded as if I was a sex slave. This strangely turned me on and I swallowed the thick tangy load and kept sucking till it was clean and he pulled it out of my mouth. Then he went down on me again like a hungry animal. By now I was rock hard and so close I could be arrested for tail gaiting. When I thought I was about to cum he stopped, raised my legs onto his shoulders, and guided his now much bigger cock between my ass cheeks. I was scared he was going to start ramming me like a jackhammer but no. He starts rubbing it so gently against my hole. His precum starts to leak out and lubricate all around my hole. It was starting to get so hot in my room. The more he moved his cock and rocked his hips grinding his cock between my ass cheeks against my hole made me want him to just shove it in but he didn’t. He just kept on rubbing my hole warming up my peach and torturing me with pleasure. He was pushing me to my limits. I could take no more so I said, “Put it in already.” And he took his hand and pushed down on the head of his dick as he kept on with his movements and he slowly let it go in and out over and over until I couldn’t take it any longer. I grabbed his ass with both hands and pulled it into me, so he popped it in me very quick which is not what I wanted. His big girthy uncut cock went in so fast that I went into shock. I could hardly move a muscle of my body. The sudden pain of him invading my body felt like nothing I could explain in words. It was like the first time when I lost my virginity to a football player in high school in the backseat of his car. Leo bent down and started kissing my neck, nibbling on my earlobe. Doing anything he could think, to distract me from the pain that he knew I was feeling. As the pain subsided he could tell and he started to gently rock his cock bit by bit in and out. It felt so different than any other cock I had felt inside me before. It was a very pleasurable experience. Like a pair of satin underwear running over my skin. Even though I hate satin underwear. Why is my mind thinking of so many other things? Am I trying to escape what is happening? This feeling is so amazing I never want him to stop. This uncut cock feels like the best thing I’ve ever had inside me. He started moving more. Thrusting and grinding between my legs stretching my hole like no one else has before. I can’t believe this is all happening. First Eric and now Leo. How is this even possible? They are both tops. What about Ethan?

Leo pounded my ass for what seemed like an eternity, but I was lost in the pleasure of it all and before I knew it I was waking up. Leo is still inside me, but growing harder by the moment. As I went to move I could feel the jolt of his cock as he busted a nut inside me. He raised his head up and said, “Finally awake?”

I must have fallen asleep while he was fucking me. I was still in the same position as I last remembered.

“We fucked for 3 hours before I noticed you started to look sleepy, so I just stopped and lay there on you and slept. Hope that’s okay.” He said. “Feeling your ass quiver as you woke up stirred my cock and I got hard again and you know morning wood. I just couldn’t hold the nut back while inside your nice warm hole”

He rolled over to the side of me and I got up because I really had to take a piss. As I got to the bathroom I felt a stir in my ass so I decided to sit and pee. As I started to pee I noticed his nut started to drip out, so I gave a little push and a flood of cum splashed down in the toilet. So much that now my ass was totally wet. I stood up and turned to look at the remnants of the aftermath of last night. A toilet of water that was mostly cum. I don’t recall seeing that much cum before.

As I walked back to bed Leo asked if I was okay and I nodded affirmative and I dropped on the bed. Leo took this as an invitation to breakfast. He lept to the foot of the bed and proceeded to start feasting on my hole. I turned my head and told him, “It went down the toilet.”, but he didn’t stop. He seemed to just enjoy eating ass and then climbed on top of me and I felt that big ole cock slip back between my cheeks but instead of rubbing it slipped right inside me almost like it was returning home. I lay there as he began filling me to the brim with pleasure and eventual cum. Then he flipped me over and went down on me again, but this time he didn’t stop as I nutted in his mouth. I could feel him swallow as every jet of cum left my body. He kept sucking till every last drop was gone and then he raised my legs up onto his shoulders and moved down to my hole again. He began to feltch his cum from my ass. Feasting on me like a delicious meal but it’s his cum that he is eating this time. I couldn’t help but be reminded how similar he was to Eric. Although, much more gentle and caring. Once he had completely emptied my ass of his load he gave it one last lick and then got up and went to the shower. I slowly went back to sleep.

Next thing I knew my phone was ringing. I answered, “Hello”

It was Eric asking what time to come over. I looked at the time. It was already 3 so I told him 7.

I got up and jumped in the shower. I had no idea what to cook but I know it had to have his favorite ingredient included in the recipe.

I started going through my recipes looking for something where I could add a little something, something to a small portion just for him. I found the perfect thing but I need to go shopping.

7 on the dot, came the knock at the door. Dinner was ready and I was ready to confront him.

I open the door to find both Leo and Eric, “Surprise” they said gleefully.

“What’s this… what’s going on? Why are you both here?” I said.

“Well…we all know what happened. Eric told me what he did and I told him about last night. So…” they both said. “We thought we could all have a little fun together. Some real playtime.”

With that, I slammed the door in their faces.

As soon as they left, I got my phone and went to call Ethan and tell him everything. It was then that I noticed his location popped up as his apartment. I had to get over there before they could tell him some crazy shit about me.
 
I grabbed my keys and drove to Ethan’s apartment. I kept replaying everything that had happened between Leo and Eric. Eric had raped me and then Leo blackmailed me into letting him fuck me. It was his fault for bringing these guys into my life. As the elevator door opened, I started to find the key to his apartment. I wanted to catch them off guard if they were there so I quietly unlocked the door and slowly made my way in. All the lights were off. I made my way to his room where he was playing music. It was unusually loud for him and not really what he liked. The door was wide open so I stuck my head in the door and quickly backed away unnoticed and in shock by what I had just seen. 9 naked black guys were standing around his room. He was in his room strapped face down to his bed one piledriving his ass and another skull fucking him. I stepped back to his living room. Now I could understand why the music was so loud. To cover the sex noises that I now could clearly make out over the music. I took out my phone and tapped his name to see what would happen. To my surprise, the music suddenly stopped and he answered the phone. “Hey babe, what’s up?” he said. I couldn’t believe he even bothered to answer.

So I said, “Oh, was just thinking about you so I just wanted to hear your voice because I miss you.”

To which he said, “Oh, I miss you too and I can’t wait to get home. This whole trip has been a pain in the ass and I can’t wait to get back to you and get our whole situation resolved.” As he spoke I walked towards his room and proceeded to walk in the bedroom and slapped him on the ass and asked if I could join.

He jumped up shocked still holding the phone and said, “Why are you here?”

Then I angrily said, “I think I told you on the phone I was missing you, but I left out the part where Eric raped me and that Leo had blackmailed me. None of that matters because I now realize you are just a ho. How many of you guys have nutted in his ass tonight”. They all raised their hands. “Thought so! I ran out of his place, got in my car, and drove home.

At this point, I was done with all of them.

An hour after getting home there came a knock at my door. I opened the door to find all 3 guys. Ethan Leo and Eric standing there.

“I have nothing to say to either of you” I exclaimed very defiantly.

“Chris, please hear us out,” Ethan said. “We know we have wronged you but let us explain.”

I could tell there was something more so I let them in and said, “30 minutes tops”.

Over the next hour, they went into all the kinky sexual details about all their relationships and why they didn’t work out. This made no sense because Ethan was an obvious submissive bottom and both Eric and Leo were dominant aggressive tops. Then they told me the one thing that made it all fit. Ethan could never be satisfied by 1 man or even 9 tops. He needed more. His biggest desire was to have another bottom who would enjoy these things with him. He wanted to watch and be watched by someone he loved and someone who loved him. Share the kinky sex watching each other getting plowed and bred balls deep over and over by random big dick-muscled dominant aggressive tops. I couldn’t help but think back at my situation. I had enjoyed Eric raping me and using my body. I enjoyed remembering it so much I got so hard I had to jack off at work and then there was Leo. I didn’t have to give in to him. I had done nothing willingly wrong. I let him do it because deep down I wanted to be dominated by him in a similar way that Eric had done previously. My thoughts raced as they explained everything to me.

“So, what is it that you want now? Did you arrange all of this? Did you set me up? Did you arrange for him to rape me against my will? Did you arrange for Leo to blackmail me? Did you expect me to curtail them and let them dominate me like they have done to you? He nodded!

“I saw everything Leo did, I was there in the room. I beat off watching him eat your hole and then I shot my load all over your ass and then he licked it all off and used it as lube to fuck you and breed you multiple times over the night. I even filled a condom full of my cum, tied it up, and left it on the side table as a trophy for him to keep. Then Leo he was so eager to please me, he set up his phone pointing at you so I could watch live since you would be able to see me if I were in your bedroom, but you never noticed you were being live-streamed to my phone via a Zoom call. I could hear the pain, as you forced him inside you too quickly, and then you gave in to the pleasure. I could hear you tell him to put it in already because he was just enjoying teasing your hole. I so enjoyed watching you, and now I want you to watch me, while I also watch you. So chose, Eric or Leo?”

Was this a dream? A nightmare? Possibly real? Dare I try this? “Leo”, I declared.

So we all walked to my room where the 3 of them began to undress me. Leo knelt down in front of me and Eric knelt behind me. One eating my ass, the other sucking my dick. Ethan for the first time I saw naked in my room. Now I understand why we had never had sex. Our attraction to each other was so intense but we were both bottoms so it would have never worked sexually unless there was something more. Ethan stepped in front of me and we started making out as Leo and Eric repositioned themselves. Leo started eating my ass and Eric dove into Ethan. They moved us onto the bed. Ethan was on his back in a missionary position while they placed me face-to-face with him in a doggie-style position as they continued eating us out. We continued making out as if no one else were there, until I felt Leo rubbing his cock against my hole again. I looked and saw that Eric was doing the same to Ethan. They gave us both a little push so both of us were cock to face. I went down on Ethan and he started sucking me as well. I was sucking his dick while watching Eric thrusting against Ethan's hole. It was almost like I was watching myself. All 4 of us were in sync. I watched Eric slip inside Ethan and I could feel it happening because Leo was doing the same to me. This time no pain. Leo had already been inside me the night before and slept inside me and now he was back. Leo with his wonderful pelvic thrust and grinding movement had me so over the top in a moment of pure bliss. I couldn’t hold back. I busted in Ethan’s mouth. I could hear him moan as he enjoyed my cum. I could hear him mumble, “Tangy, like when we kissed.” I was both embarrassed and turned on. Suddenly both guys ramped up the speed of their movements. I was suddenly part of a fuck machine with 4 parts. With 2 thrusting and 2 sucking. Ethan was still sucking my cock but it was starting to get hard again due to all the pleasure. Then suddenly Ethan grabbed the back of my head and forced me down on his cock and he thrusted upwards shoving his cock down my throat as a rush of cum burst out of him and straight down my throat. I almost choked on it. I just kept swallowing and he kept cumming. It was like someone had turned the knob on to this water hose in my mouth. With 2 last jerks, he releases the last of his load. I ran my tongue around the head of his dick. Ensuring I had cleaned him all up. There were still 2 loads left, but now I was hard again and getting close to releasing another load. Ethan was now holding onto my ass. Spreading it wide open. Leo quickly pulled out and then slammed it back in several times. So I reached for Ethan’s ass and then Eric began to copy the movements of Leo. Slamming his cock, balls deep inside Ethan. Before the seventh slam, Ethan had gotten fully erect again and was throbbing. I went back down on him again sucking him like a starving animal. I craved the taste of his warm milk. I had barely tasted it before because his cock was in my throat when he came. I did get a little taste as I pulled off to clean off the head of his dick. He in turn was sucking my cock while still spreading my ass wide open. Leo was still grinding his cock so perfectly in my ass. Leo suddenly stopped and pulled out. Then he rammed it in so very hard he hit my prostate and I came instantly down Ethan’s throat and he moaned with pleasure as I felt him loose his load in my mouth. Not quite a jet of cum. I suppose the guys before had fucked a few loads out of him and I was getting their leftovers but this load was nice. It was very sweet almost like candy. Then things took a change. Eric reached down and pulled his cock from Ethan’s ass and shoved it in my mouth as he flooded my throat with his nut. It wasn’t sweet, or tangy. It didn’t have any flavor. It was just very watery. Then I felt Leo pull out and flood Ethan with his load, but not all. He quickly returned his cock to my ass where I could feel him still cumming. Eric walked around the bed beside Leo as he pulled out of me, they all 3 started licking my ass. Ethan caught the cum spilling from my ass and both Eric and Leo shared my hole. This was so fucking hot I came all over Ethan’s chest. I could not believe this was happening. Before I knew what I was doing I had flipped around and started licking my cum off of his chest. Eric and Leo joined me and we all 3 started sharing the cum with Ethan. I would lick up some cum and spit it into his mouth and he would swallow it. We all kept feeding him my cum until we were all spent and exhausted.

The next thing I remember is my alarm going off. It was time to get up. Now there were 3 other people in my bed. For the first time in my life, I have been sexually fulfilled.

Weeks, then months went by and life seemed so perfect. We got a house together as a foursome. We would switch up but always together. At times we would invite others. Sometimes I would sit and watch guy after guy railed Ethan and other times he would sit back and enjoy watching me make love with Ethan, Leo, and 30 other guys. Our sex lives were never the same. There was no coupling, no partners, no ownership. We all just belong to one another and anyone else we wanted to join. Outside of sex, we were 4 guys all in love with each other. We had a private ceremony where we all married each other. All 4 of our names were engraved on the inside of each ring.

Then there came a knock at the door….”Ethan, how did you get outside so quick and what’s with these guys, we’re about to eat?”

From the kitchen, Ethan responds, “What do you mean, I’m in the kitchen.

Ethan walked to the door and said, “Oh, I wasn’t expecting you today. I’d like to introduce you to my identical twin brother, his name is Dale.” “Who are your friends?”

Dale responds, “I guess we are more alike than just our looks. I’m gay and these are my boyfriends.”

4 boyfriends, I guess they are exactly alike in looks and what they like sexually as well.