He himself, I’d say in overall attractiveness is a 9.
If I just viewed him in physical attractiveness, I’d say he’s an 8 - relatively good looks, good body. He has a nice smile, pretty eyes, and alright muscle tone. I’ve of course seen much better looking people and better looking bodies, but he’s good nonetheless.
If I viewed him in sexual attractiveness, e.g. how nice is his dick, does he have exciting sex, do I think he’d deliver amazing orgasms, then I’d rank him a straight-up 10. That dick is one of the handsomest sexiest cocks I’ve ever seen - it’s jaw-droppingly long, eye-wideningly thick, it has great veinage, a beautiful foreskin, a gorgeously plump head, a nicely low-hanging big sack of testicles, and he shoots an impressively sized load with incredible force and distance. Complete package, he has, and it is nicely proportionate-looking, meaning its dimensions don’t look imbalanced or out-of-place. Mainly, his huge dick fits him well. In his sexual escapades, his partners seem totally satisfied. He’s got it all going for him in the sex department.
So I just went with the median between his physical attractiveness (8) and his sexual attractiveness (10) haha - a nice solid 9.