Friendly Threesome (True Story)

[Comeover]

One of the bad things about a breakup is the possibility of running into your ex. In the gay world, that seems to be an even higher probability. I had tried to stay out of the gay bars for a few months, as I was not in the mindset to run into my ex. I reached a point where I was ready for the chance encounter, so I headed to meet up some friends for a happy hour bar meet-up.

Everything was going great, until I spotted one of my ex’s best friends. Post breakup, I had unfollowed all of his friends. It wasn’t really a sacrifice as they never really felt like they were my friends. Allen was one of the nicer ones, specifically one of my ex’s friends that we had a threesome with on multiple occasions during our relationship. I tried to play it cool and just pretend I hadn’t seen him.

I stood by the bar waiting for my turn to order, when I could see Allen walking towards me, I prepared for impact.

“So…are you just going to pretend we don’t know each other?” He said as he leaned on the bar right next to me.

“Hey, of course not. Sorry.” I gave him a hug.

“Look don’t want you to ever feel uncomfortable running into me. I liked you, even without the sex”, he jokingly (but maybe not) mumbled.

He picked up my tab for the drinks I was ordering for my friends and me. He even ordered a couple tequila shots for him and I. We chatted a bit about life, and I went on my way.

As I was settling into bed, I received a message from Allen on Instagram, which followed by a “follow request”.

“Sorry if this is weird but wanted to say it was nice catching up. If you are ever up for it, we should meet up for some drinks or grab a bite to eat one day” His message read.

I accepted his request, and we slowly started corresponding. After a couple weeks that turned into us actually texting. Our conversations were friendly and flirty so he deserved actual texts from me. We would sometimes have a bit more than flirty messages on a late night exchange.

We finally decided it was time to hangout. I suggested a lunch on Friday, as that would be a short and harmless meet-up (at least that’s what I told myself). He convinced me that the only option I had was for him to pick me up, just made “sense”. Even though he wasn’t my friend, Allen was someone I really liked during my time in my ex’s Robert life. But over the past few weeks of messaging, I actually thought he could be a good friend.

Lunch was great, somehow we ended up having two bottles of white wine. Which then lead to us ending up at a couple bars. On the third bar, we ran into my ex. I never asked Allen about my ex or asked if he was aware of our new friendship. Allen seem to be caught off guard, as Robert walked up to us. I hadn’t seen my ex, much less talked to him in person. He would randomly sent me messages on Grindr when he was drunk about how me missed my ass and dick. Drunk me would respond but it was always late night and just sex talk.

I walked away and headed to the bathroom. I wasn’t emotional distraught it was just a weird situation, now add Robert seeing my hanging out with his best friend. I texted Allen that I was ready to head somewhere else, he quickly found me outside and we headed to another bar. At a certain point the night started getting away from me, I could tell it was time to wrap it up.
Allen somehow seemed sober and composed.

“If you are up for it, come back to my place for a drink or two. I’ll get you a cab from there back to your place” Allen suggested. Off we went.

The drinks of course ended up being…us making out on his couch and him drunkly leading me to his bed. I remembered falling onto his bed but next thing I remembered was waking up naked next to Allen. He lived in a skyscraper with full windows as his walls, no way you could sleep in late with the sun. I got up and went to his bathroom. Started trying to puzzle the night together and find my clothes.

“That was hot last night” Allen coyly smiled as I walked out of the bathroom.

“Don’t remember much”.

“Well we made out. Got naked. You gave me an amazing bj then you didn’t let me fuck you. So not much to tell” Allen laughed.

We started hanging out from time to time but daily texts were exchanged. He slowly would bring up my ex, Robert, and how Robert was fine we were friends. Robert actually told Allen we should all hangout one day. That wasn’t a surprise as Robert was messaging me on Grindr even when he wasn’t drunk. Telling me we should hookup, he’s fine with my friendship with Allen… Robert has one of the best dicks I ever experienced, so of course I would of loved for us to be fuck buddies but I just didn’t trust myself jumping back into bed that soon of our breakup.

Allen and I had hung out several times since that drunken night of making out but had not ended up naked again. I still felt weird about his closeness with my ex. Believe me, I was messy but even I try and keep it a little classy sometimes.

Allen and I went for a dinner one night, which then lead to going to meet up some of his friends at some straight bars. Most of the group wanted to call it an early night, Allen and I were feeling the tequila and wanted to continue. One of his friends, Will, stated he would be down for the gay bars. The three of us Uber’ed over. Will was hot, my type a white boy with a nice athletic built. Didn’t hurt that he was super nice and flirty. After a couple bars, Will excused himself to go meetup a couple friends. He stated he would meet us up in a bit. Allen and I continued drinking and dancing the night away.

“Hey let’s head out before they close so we don’t have to wait for a car long. I told Will to come meet us up at my place once he’s done with his friends” Allen screamed over the music.

I was tipsy but the tequila shots continued at Allen’s place. We discussed how hot I found Will.

“He gets around. Maybe I can make something happen tonight with you both.” Allen said as he poured another shot into my eager open mouth.

I was getting pretty tired and exponentially drunk. I jumped in the shower then slid into Allen’s bed as he cleaned up. I heard a knock at the door, as my eyes started closing. I could hear some voices coming from Allen’s bathroom and the shower running. Then the water stopped, and could feel someone getting into bed.

The night was the opposite of the daytime inside Allen’s apartment. His bedroom faced to an open bayou, so on a clouded night, it was pitched dark if the lights were off. I felt Allen wrap his arms around my body.

“Got you what you wanted. I just need to get what I want too.” Allen whispered into my ear.

 

[Virat69]

Is there a second part?

 

[Ikke.ik]

Hot

 

[George_Pantelis]

Great start. Looking forward to the rest

 

[Comeover]

I could feel Allen’s hard dick pressed against my ass. I had not had sex with Allen in such a long time, and I had been hoping it would happen again at some point.

“Get under the covers and make sure we are nice and hard for what’s to come in a bit” Allen said coyly.

I got under the covers and started with Allen. He didn’t have the biggest dick in the world but I remember it being a pretty dick (we all know those types). With one of my hands I reached to find Will’s dick, and boy did I find it. It was hard already but thick…and long. I moved my mouth over to his dick and tried my best to deep throat it. I could feel tears welling up in eyes from taking that dick as deep as I could. I felt his hand push my head farther down his shaft and he started moaning. I felt the bedsheets being pulled off the bed

“Get on all fours. Show us that nice hole” Allen spoke as he put a blind fold over my eyes. I immediately got hard.

Even though my eyes were blindfolded I could see a bit of light. He must of turned on a lamp. I was on all fours with my back arched down. I could feel hands grabbing my ass, pulling at my dick, and grabbing my chest.

“Open up baby” Allen whispered into my ear.

I felt his dick on my lips, so I followed directions. At the same time I could feel Will eating my ass out. His warm tongue circling my eager hole. Allen pulled his dick out and I could feel his mouth take its place.

“You want that big dick in you?” Allen took a break from making out with me.

All I could do was let out a moan signaling I was ready. I felt Will’s dick slide into me. I could feel the pain but I didn’t dare mess up this moment. I was too horny and drunk to stop it. My hole cupped his dick in a way that automatically felt you could cum at any moment. I was doing my best to control my moaning but they kept coming.

Will grabbed on to both of my shoulders and made me arch my back even further. At the same time, I could hear a phone camera start recording, the beeping noise is recognizable to many of us. I was no prude so I pretended I didn’t hear and kept focusing on being railed.

Will finally pulled out and I could feel the changing of the bodies behind me, it must be time for Allen to take his turn. Nothing slid in. I could barely hear but it sounded like they were making out. I made a slight move to turn around and join.

“No. You are staying like that. He isn’t done yet” Allen firmly responded to my movement.

I could sense a body position itself next to mine, whoever it was must pf assumed a doggy style position. I could hear him start moaning, maybe it was Allen getting fucked. I wasn’t sure. I listened but didn’t dare move.

After a few minutes I felt Wills dick slide back into my hole. Allen came around and put his dick back into my mouth.

“You are going to be a good boy and take both of loads.” Allen said as he increased his thrusting into my mouth.

I had sex with Allen before hut never remember him being this dominant in his verbiage. I loved it. After a few minutes I felt Allen’s load burst into the back of my mouth. Just as he pulled out, I felt the tensing of Wills body and his load enter me. By this point I was moaning and sweating.

“Don’t you move. I’m not done with you” Allen whispered once again into my ear.

I could hear the commotion from two bodies move around. I could sense they were moving into the living room, then I heard the front door. I held my position. I felt a hand reach for my blindfold. Allen pulled it off. He notion for my to join him in the shower. In the shower he finally relieved me off my load with his mouth. We both cleaned up and headed to bed.

The next morning I woke up to a pounding headache but with no regrets of the nights unfolding. Allen and I made our way to the living room.

“Last night was hot” Allen said as he poured me a glass of water from the kitchen.

“It was. I was hoping I would get fucked by you too” I replied.

“Just have to wait for next time”, he hesitated, “if you are a good boy.”

I never liked to overstay my welcome at Allen’s. We had a little chat then I went on my way. We chatted normally during the week. Thursday evening, I finally brought up the video I’m sure was recorded.

“So am I never going to see this video you took? You didn’t want me to see anything that night. I atleast deserve a memory; that isn’t just a sore hole filled with cum”.

He responded, “No idea what you are talking about ”.

We made plans to do a movie night at his place the next evening, if his plans fell through.

“Sorry, I thought I was going to get out of this but looks like we need to push movie night for tomorrow. Sorry.” Allens text read.

I ended up making plans to meet up my friends for a little happy hour bar hop. We jumped around for a bit and on my last planned stop, I saw Will standing alone at a bar table.

“Hey” I went in for a hug.

“Her stranger” Will responded with a tight hug.

“That was fun the other night.” I said after a few minutes of small talk.

“It was. Sorry yall left before I could catch up to yall again” Will responded as he took a sip of his drink.

I looked at him, he could tell I was confused.

“Did you blackout? I went to meet up my friends and when I texted Allen to meet up, he said you were already asleep at his place. I ended up just going home” Will explained.

 

[Pepijn]

Who could it have been?

 

[Jewm4321]

Who could it have been?

Oooh that’s wild. Was it Robert?

 

[Comeover]

I couldn’t even process the fact, that Allen had made up an elaborate plan to have someone fuck me but then state it was Will. I played it off around Will and continued my night out. Upon my arrival home, I text Allen “what are you to?”…no response.

The next morning I awoke to a couple sexual texts from Allen, and even a picture (of his dick).

“Looks like someone was having a fun night. Good morning”, I responded.

After a couple hours he started responding and we made plans to meet up at his place around seven for movie night. As much as I wanted to ask about the “Will situation”, I wanted to play it smart and collected. I headed over that evening and everything was normal. Allen was in a drinking mood but I tried to pace myself (a challenge). After a couple movies, he was pretty drunk and tired.

“So are you staying the night and cuddling”, Allen stated as he got up from the couch stumbling.

I said I would, but was going to clean up a bit. I suggested he shower and get into bed, I would join him momentarily. I could hear the shower running and the shower door open then close. I began cleaning up the snacks and glasses that had accumulated. I noticed his phone on the couch and moved it aside. As I was finishing up his phone lit-up, I could see the text very clear.

“Last night was fun. I hope”, I couldn’t see the full message from the preview but it was from Robert.

Allen had told me had plans the evening before but he hadn’t mention the details. Of course Robert was his friend but something about the text raised my suspicions even more. I hit the preview, and the full text popped up.

“Last night was fun. I hope you weren’t too sore this morning.” Robert’s message read.

I heard the water from the shower stop, and I put the phone back on the couch. I finished up picking up in the living room. By the time I entered the bedroom, Allen was passed out in bed. I slipped my clothes off and got in the sheets. The text could mean a few things but my mind went straight to thinking they had sex. I had no claim over either of them but I just hadn’t thought about that possibility.

I tried my best to go to sleep but it wasn’t going to happen. After some thinking, I slipped out of bed and went to the living room. I knew Allen’s passcode so I entered the digits and his phone unlocked. I first decided to look in his photo app to see if the video from two nights ago was in there. No luck.

I opened up his texts from Robert. They had hung out the night before, met up for dinner. As I scrolled up on the text, I saw a video and the preview shot…it was me..sucking Allen’s dick. Allen must of sent the video from two nights ago to Robert. I turned the volume down on the phone and pushed play. Not only was it me sucking off Allen, it was Robert fucking me doggy style. What the hell was going. I stopped the video.

I kept scrolling up on their texts and I was reading as they planned out that whole night. They had texts from weeks prior talking about all three of us having sex together. Allen telling Robert, that he didn’t think I would be up for that. Robert agreeing, bringing up our late night Grindr messages that never actually lead to us meeting up. Not only were they talking about me, but multiple conversations about them meeting up and having sex the past few months. One of the texts Robert sent Allen, I couldn’t believe.

“You are not allowed to fuck him. You can mess around but that hole isn’t for you” Robert texted Allen.

The night we hung out with Will, Allen texted Robert and told him to come over to his place. I was speechless, standing in the room right next to a sleeping Allen. I didn’t know if I should just leave or what response to have to this. I sent a copy of the video to my phone and deleted it from Allen’s side of our text.

 

[Pepijn]

Wicked.
So curious what happens next.

 

[Comeover]

As much as the experience a few nights ago was hot and sexual, it was all under false pretenses. The thought of this “budding” friendship with Allen being some sort of mirage was truly messing with my mind. I got back into and tried my best to fall asleep. After a long stretch of thinking, I finally did pass out.

I awoke to Allen’s mouth on my dick. I was taken aback for a moment. How could he just be acting as if nothing was wrong…of course, he didn’t know I had uncovered this information the night before. I let him finish blowing me until I came in his mouth.

“What a great way to start the weekend” Allen said as he came out from under the covers.

“Sure is. Well I need to head out, I have some things to follow through this morning”, I got out of bed.

“Uhm okay. You up for meeting up tonight? Think some friends are going out to the bars” Allen asked.

“I’ll let you know.” I responded.

I left Allen’s place as quick as I could. Once home I replayed the video I had sent myself. Robert fucking me and fucking Allen. In what world did they think this was a good idea. Were they an item or just fuck buddies? So many questions arose from one night.

Allen texted me about tonight but I hadn’t responded. I didn’t know just how to play this. Part of me just wanted to ask him straight out but also a part of me was kind of hurt by Allen’s deceit.

“Hey. What are you up to tonight?” I typed out.

Shortly after the message sent, I got a response.

“Nothing planned. What’s up?” Robert responded on Grindr.

I asked Robert to meet me up that evening for some drinks. I decided to test the waters, see if Robert would come clean. We hadn’t “hungout” since our breakup, but he was down to meet.

On the way to the bar, Allen called. I didn’t respond. I knew he would know something was up, I always responded but I just didn’t quite want to reply to him just yet.

Robert walked in and we started just on some light conversation. After a while I decided to start poking.

“Have you had any fun lately?” I questioned.

“Not really. Same ol’. What about you?” Robert responded.

“I mean I don’t know if I should talk to you about this, might be a bit weird…” I said as I took a sip.

Robert rolled his eyes “We haven’t been together for months”.

“Well you know I have been hanging out with Allen for a bit. We’ve had some fun together.” I said.

“Oh shit, really? Have yall had sex?” Robert questioned.

“Yeah a few times, he’s been fucking me” I lied.

I was looking to see if any reaction would come from Robert. I didn’t notice any change in his demeanor.

“Damn, that’s kind of hot”, Robert replied.

This guy really wasn’t going to give me anything. Robert wasn’t dumb but I knew when it came to sexual things he was a big open book.

“Not going to lie. I was thinking a while ago about those threesomes we had when we were together…the ones Allen was involved with” I pushed even further.

“Yeah those were really hot”, Robert said.

“I wouldn’t have mind having another one of those sessions lately. Probably be weird though…us two having sex again, much less with Allen involved” I decided to take it up a notch.

“I mean you never know. Who knows if Allen would be up for that. I would be so down for that” Robert responded in a calm manner.

I was figuring this situation wouldn’t lead to Robert coming clean. I’m not sure what I expected but it wasn’t going to come easily out of him. I slowly started maneuvering the conversation away from this topic. Just then I felt someone grab my shoulder. It was Allen.

“Well well, now I see why you’ve been ignoring me all day. Cheating on me with you ex” Allen coyly muttered.