Initial under-/overestimation of someone's cock size

[FitCollegeDude]

Have you guys ever initially under- or overestimated someone's soft or hard size, for some reason, just to be proven wrong?
​

1. A straight buddy of mine, we started going to the gym together, and I was quite looking forward to seeing him naked. We stripped off and headed for the showers. After a while, I looked over and saw his huge bush and his cock was not too impressive. I was quite disappointed. So next time I wasn't that excited anymore, but looked down after a while. This time he was neatly trimmed and his cock was hanging pretty big, I definitely had to do a double take there. Last time he was probably having some huge gym shrinkage and combined with the shorter pubes, it was quite impressive now.
   ​
2. I was sitting at the sauna with some guy opposite of me, with his legs spread apart. This was a great opportunity to check out his package, but he seemed kinda small. Then he got up, and oh boy, his cock literally unfolded. Not sure how he was hiding this between his legs, but damn. I was certainly staring as it swung past my eyes.
   ​
3. Another sauna guy. He was cute but his cock definitely wasn't big. I happened to shower just opposite of him and checked him out a few times. That's when I noticed his soft cock getting bigger and bigger, until he finally had a nice big soft cock hanging between his legs. Might've been a semi, but it looked pretty soft to me. Damn, that sauna must've put some stress on his cock, and now was able to relax a bit under the shower.
   ​
4. This is more about the expectation of a bigger soft cock. I have this friend, who rumored to have a huge cock. My ex apparently sucked him off once and confirmed it. He always strips off when drunk and shows off his cock, which I've unfortunately always missed. So I was pretty excited when I went to the gym with him and would be able to shower with him for the first time. I even fluffed mine nicely so I wouldn't be too embarrassed by his monster cock. And yeah, his soft cock was very disappointing. Like, I was hanging at least twice as big as he was. I'd kill to know what he was thinking at that moment. He's always bragging about his cock, while I never say anything about mine, and then I step into the shower with a big softie
   So it's very possible he's a huge grower, if it's true what my friends said. Apparently he did the helicopter a few times for them. Of course not possible with his soft cock, so he'd need to work up a nice big semi for that. Maybe when he's drunk, he's constantly horny and always walking around with a semi. Thinking about that is definitely a huge turn-on, knowing how small he's soft.​

 

[Snps21]

I’m still amazed at how many guys (despite having dicks themselves) seem unaware of the concept of growers versus show-ers. You can’t judge a book by its cover: a small softie can turn into a monster, and a big softie may barely grow at all.

 

[thickcockjames]

I haven’t done that because I’m not typically sizing up guy’s cocks. Buuuuut, I have had many people do it to me. I’m 5’7” so when I pull my cock out people are usually pretty surprised. Haha

 

[Marine21]

I haven’t done that because I’m not typically sizing up guy’s cocks. Buuuuut, I have had many people do it to me. I’m 5’7” so when I pull my cock out people are usually pretty surprised. Haha

Knew a guy who 5’ 5” and 4” max but thick as a fucking Coke can. He was fun… crazy, but fun.

 

[HungBtmVegas]

I ALWAYS underestimate cocks because most men lie or are delusional about how big they are. I can eyeball a legitimate 8" pretty well because my cock is a little over and I can definitely eyeball 10" now because I've only encountered one man with a legitimate 10" in my life out of the thousands I've seen in person.

 

[MWUS7x6]

My flaccid size can vary a lot with temperature, mood, and even just how I'm sitting or standing. You can't tell anything from it.

 

[HungBtmVegas]

My flaccid size can vary a lot with temperature, mood, and even just how I'm sitting or standing. You can't tell anything from it.

Yeah, I never make assumptions based on flaccid size. I've met some VERY extreme growers before.

 

[lapdog2001]

I’m still amazed at how many guys (despite having dicks themselves) seem unaware of the concept of growers versus show-ers. You can’t judge a book by its cover: a small softie can turn into a monster, and a big softie may barely grow at all.

Yes, exactly! Flaccid size is completely and totally irrelevant to erect size

My flaccid size can vary a lot with temperature, mood, and even just how I'm sitting or standing. You can't tell anything from it.

My flaccid size has ranged from maybe an inch in cold weather, to maybe 5 inches, but generally 'hangs out' between 2-3 inches. Like you, it can be 20 different sizes in one day depending on what I'm doing, thinks, or anything. No matter where it starts, it always ends up at 7 by 6 when erect!

 

[fightermike]

i had a roommate who had a small softie, maybe was like 2-3 inches compared to my 5 incher. but then i saw him in the morning with morning wood once and was stunned that he was actually packing much more lol prob close to 8 inches! no wonder he kept pulling girls left and right ha

 

[curious6.5]

Flacid size means very little. I'm 3ish soft and 6.5 hard. A buddy of mine is like 5 soft and 5.5 rock hard. One thing I've noticed is that the larger balled guys tend to grow more and have larger cocks.

 

[halcyondays]

Have you guys ever initially under- or overestimated someone's soft or hard size, for some reason, just to be proven wrong?

I haven't but not long after I turned 18 rumors that mine was a foot long erect started getting back to me spread by girlfriends who over estimated what I had.

 

[BIGdickRodney]

I am definitely a grower. I have been bragged about several times from women and men alike. However, there have been a couple instances where I don't get hard or even semi hard, and while not small, my flacid penis is just fine, but not special. When I am at peak erection (or even peak semi for that matter) the difference is night and day. I've even had instances where my full erection was not as 'full' or engorged as usual, and there have been times when someone sees it for the first time, and I can tell they are not quite as excited about it as they were when initially seeing my pics or vids, or when they were talking with a friend who mentioned how BIG I was. Then, eventually they see it again in its fully formed thickness and musculature, as well as its veiny/blood vessled "maxed out" version, and I get that sly devious smile from them of "Oh wow, now there is that HUGE cock I heard about and seen in photos!".

 

[explosionerection]

I´m a big shower at 5.7 inches soft but it also grows to 7 inches when hard. Happy it's not only a shower as it also grows a lot when erect.

Been with some other dudes who were showers but barely grew at all. Maybe I´m both a shower and a grower? I don't know

 

[Hardybob]

i had a roommate who had a small softie, maybe was like 2-3 inches compared to my 5 incher. but then i saw him in the morning with morning wood once and was stunned that he was actually packing much more lol prob close to 8 inches! no wonder he kept pulling girls left and right ha

Gotta love the super grower!

 

[Magnum10x2]

I've had countless encounters where the girl was literally shocked when I get fully hard.

 

[rope9839]

One of my oldest friends is 6' 10", built like a pro wrestler. His penis is maybe 4 inches. It's almost like a cruel joke on him. I know women who have dated him that were very surprised when they found out.

 

[thebedwizard93]

Have you guys ever initially under- or overestimated someone's soft or hard size, for some reason, just to be proven wrong?
​

1. A straight buddy of mine, we started going to the gym together, and I was quite looking forward to seeing him naked. We stripped off and headed for the showers. After a while, I looked over and saw his huge bush and his cock was not too impressive. I was quite disappointed. So next time I wasn't that excited anymore, but looked down after a while. This time he was neatly trimmed and his cock was hanging pretty big, I definitely had to do a double take there. Last time he was probably having some huge gym shrinkage and combined with the shorter pubes, it was quite impressive now.​
2. I was sitting at the sauna with some guy opposite of me, with his legs spread apart. This was a great opportunity to check out his package, but he seemed kinda small. Then he got up, and oh boy, his cock literally unfolded. Not sure how he was hiding this between his legs, but damn. I was certainly staring as it swung past my eyes.​
3. Another sauna guy. He was cute but his cock definitely wasn't big. I happened to shower just opposite of him and checked him out a few times. That's when I noticed his soft cock getting bigger and bigger, until he finally had a nice big soft cock hanging between his legs. Might've been a semi, but it looked pretty soft to me. Damn, that sauna must've put some stress on his cock, and now was able to relax a bit under the shower.​
4. This is more about the expectation of a bigger soft cock. I have this friend, who rumored to have a huge cock. My ex apparently sucked him off once and confirmed it. He always strips off when drunk and shows off his cock, which I've unfortunately always missed. So I was pretty excited when I went to the gym with him and would be able to shower with him for the first time. I even fluffed mine nicely so I wouldn't be too embarrassed by his monster cock. And yeah, his soft cock was very disappointing. Like, I was hanging at least twice as big as he was. I'd kill to know what he was thinking at that moment. He's always bragging about his cock, while I never say anything about mine, and then I step into the shower with a big softie
   So it's very possible he's a huge grower, if it's true what my friends said. Apparently he did the helicopter a few times for them. Of course not possible with his soft cock, so he'd need to work up a nice big semi for that. Maybe when he's drunk, he's constantly horny and always walking around with a semi. Thinking about that is definitely a huge turn-on, knowing how small he's soft.​

I love your sauna stories! They get me all nostalgic for my own sauna/pool/locker room stories!

 

[Minititan]

Have you guys ever initially under- or overestimated someone's soft or hard size, for some reason, just to be proven wrong?
​

1. A straight buddy of mine, we started going to the gym together, and I was quite looking forward to seeing him naked. We stripped off and headed for the showers. After a while, I looked over and saw his huge bush and his cock was not too impressive. I was quite disappointed. So next time I wasn't that excited anymore, but looked down after a while. This time he was neatly trimmed and his cock was hanging pretty big, I definitely had to do a double take there. Last time he was probably having some huge gym shrinkage and combined with the shorter pubes, it was quite impressive now.​
2. I was sitting at the sauna with some guy opposite of me, with his legs spread apart. This was a great opportunity to check out his package, but he seemed kinda small. Then he got up, and oh boy, his cock literally unfolded. Not sure how he was hiding this between his legs, but damn. I was certainly staring as it swung past my eyes.​
3. Another sauna guy. He was cute but his cock definitely wasn't big. I happened to shower just opposite of him and checked him out a few times. That's when I noticed his soft cock getting bigger and bigger, until he finally had a nice big soft cock hanging between his legs. Might've been a semi, but it looked pretty soft to me. Damn, that sauna must've put some stress on his cock, and now was able to relax a bit under the shower.​
4. This is more about the expectation of a bigger soft cock. I have this friend, who rumored to have a huge cock. My ex apparently sucked him off once and confirmed it. He always strips off when drunk and shows off his cock, which I've unfortunately always missed. So I was pretty excited when I went to the gym with him and would be able to shower with him for the first time. I even fluffed mine nicely so I wouldn't be too embarrassed by his monster cock. And yeah, his soft cock was very disappointing. Like, I was hanging at least twice as big as he was. I'd kill to know what he was thinking at that moment. He's always bragging about his cock, while I never say anything about mine, and then I step into the shower with a big softie
   So it's very possible he's a huge grower, if it's true what my friends said. Apparently he did the helicopter a few times for them. Of course not possible with his soft cock, so he'd need to work up a nice big semi for that. Maybe when he's drunk, he's constantly horny and always walking around with a semi. Thinking about that is definitely a huge turn-on, knowing how small he's soft.​

My story is similar to yours with number 1 but the other way around.

When I first went to the gym with my best friend I was buzzing to get to change together and see him naked. I’d seen his dick before but not like this.

When we both started to strip down I took a peek and he had a pretty average dick but it was incredibly smooth and perfectly shaped which turned me on like mad instantly. He must’ve also been looking at me too because he blurted out ‘fuck me you’ve got a monster cock’. Thankfully seeing him naked had only given me a semi but having him say that made me absolutely rock solid.

We were alone in the changing rooms and he placed his now also hard cock next to mine measuring them against each other, I did have a pic of that but I’ve since lost it unfortunately. I do still have some of his pics from other times we were messing about together though.