At what size would you consider a dick small ?

Very, very simple answer, I'm surprised no one has posted it. Dicks are small when they are smaller than mine. Period. (As my avitar suggests, I measure a legitimate 1 milleobe. My spelling may be off, but as I learned in high school, a milleobe is 1/1000 the height of the Washington Monument. )
 
I think there are many more big ones out there than people think. I'm 6.5 x 5.5 and two different women have said that I was "small".

Wow. Ok. I guess my response would be to say that it's all relative.

Even if that's a bone pressed measurement, you would probably show 6" length. I would suspect the sincerity of a statement like that. I think most regard calling a penis small (especially if it isn't) as slightly insulting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ItsAll4Kim
I guess then you either can't measure properly or the women didn't like you at all since no sane woman would call a real legit 6.5x5.5 small.

I'm pretty close to 7" bone pressed, 6.5 is legit.

The first one was a LTR in college. We were sort of on a break and she hooked up with another guy. When we got back together, we had some pretty amazing sex and I said something along the lines of "see what you were missing?" and she kind of nervously laughed and said something like "yeah, you're almost perfect". When I asked her what would make it perfect she laughed again and said "Another inch". Evidently a guy she hooked up with while we were apart was a bit larger and she said it was "like having a poison-tipped sword"...it was just so easy for her to cum.

The other was a friend that turned into a late night hookup. She was not at all promiscuous, was with maybe 3 other guys. When I got undressed she looked a little disappointed. I asked her what was up and she said "it's cute, I've just never seen one that small". I asked her how big [last guy she hooked up with] was and she stacked her two hands around my dick, then took the bottom hand and put it on top, leaving about 2-3" of empty hand on top of my dick and said "about like that". Evidently I was the smallest of the 3.
 
I'm pretty close to 7" bone pressed, 6.5 is legit.

The first one was a LTR in college. We were sort of on a break and she hooked up with another guy. When we got back together, we had some pretty amazing sex and I said something along the lines of "see what you were missing?" and she kind of nervously laughed and said something like "yeah, you're almost perfect". When I asked her what would make it perfect she laughed again and said "Another inch". Evidently a guy she hooked up with while we were apart was a bit larger and she said it was "like having a poison-tipped sword"...it was just so easy for her to cum.

The other was a friend that turned into a late night hookup. She was not at all promiscuous, was with maybe 3 other guys. When I got undressed she looked a little disappointed. I asked her what was up and she said "it's cute, I've just never seen one that small". I asked her how big [last guy she hooked up with] was and she stacked her two hands around my dick, then took the bottom hand and put it on top, leaving about 2-3" of empty hand on top of my dick and said "about like that". Evidently I was the smallest of the 3.

Stuff like that can hurt. It's good to hear the honesty, though.

The first one never said you were small. The second one is just ignorant. Ignorant about dicks and manners. That's like if a woman took her shirt off to show c cups and you told her they were the smallest you've ever seen? Even if it's true, who does that?

When you banged her did you say wow that's loose, I didn't know it could be so loose?
 
  • Like
Reactions: ItsAll4Kim
I'm pretty close to 7" bone pressed, 6.5 is legit.

The first one was a LTR in college. We were sort of on a break and she hooked up with another guy. When we got back together, we had some pretty amazing sex and I said something along the lines of "see what you were missing?" and she kind of nervously laughed and said something like "yeah, you're almost perfect". When I asked her what would make it perfect she laughed again and said "Another inch". Evidently a guy she hooked up with while we were apart was a bit larger and she said it was "like having a poison-tipped sword"...it was just so easy for her to cum.

The other was a friend that turned into a late night hookup. She was not at all promiscuous, was with maybe 3 other guys. When I got undressed she looked a little disappointed. I asked her what was up and she said "it's cute, I've just never seen one that small". I asked her how big [last guy she hooked up with] was and she stacked her two hands around my dick, then took the bottom hand and put it on top, leaving about 2-3" of empty hand on top of my dick and said "about like that". Evidently I was the smallest of the 3.
Well that definitely sounds totally different than your initial post ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: ItsAll4Kim
Under 5"-- however, a really fat dick is really impressive regardless of length. Since I'm average girth, I feel insecure about my size and sometimes I feel small. With that in mind, any penis that is 6" in girth or above, I would consider a big cock.