IMO to me, they're not that attractive. I saw their faces. Brandt looks nothing like the alpha male type of character he plays on his website. And Nash is ok facially. But it doesn't match his body type. Not to say they aren't attractive enough in porn because compared to other offers they are equal. But BrandtsBoys has crafted itself as recruiting and showcasing the type of jocks you see portrayed on television/movies.
Think fratmen, fratpad, early gayhoopla, golden era Sean Cody, early corbinfisher, straight college men, etc.