I dig hung but if a guy is handsome enough I don't give a fuck if he's hung. When you come to a point that hung is not paramount, that's when sex can get mind blowing. Probably a lot out there that will disagree, but it's true.
Handsome. When I see a fabulous athletic body with a mouth-watering cock but topped by an ugly or arrogant face, I would go for that boy-next-door with love handles, average cock but a pretty or sympathic face.