Um...not to be a Debbie Downer, but you getting "turned off by gay men" MIGHT be a wee bit of internalized homophobia expressing itself as fear of being grouped with people that society considers "Other" or "Devalued."
In short, meaning you like having sex with men, but would never want to be openly considered by your peers and society at large as anything close to gay/bi or uh..."fruity." LOL Also seeing as you're from NJ,I'm not sure how progressive the area you live in is, so your current environment may also come into play with how you perceive your attraction towards straight(er) men.
For example, as a bi man, you might be able to code switch and not come off as queer at all until the moment you're actually with another man. You might be able to go out in public and flirt with women you find attractive - and to an extent - flirt with or interact with a masculine man and no one walking by you will think "Pfft, those guys look like queers," therefore saving yourself from any public humiliation or shame.
This is just conjecture, albeit typical.
Anyways, hope this maybe offers a little bit of insight and hope you find your hunky dreamboat.
Peace and love. <3