I found another one,not sure if the list was updated on first page but here is scott nails.
There is another picture with Jack Napier being measured and he was about 9 inches so that pic there with him being measure the ruler has to be fake.
Criss Strokes, apparently 7/7.5" (not fully hard)
http://img263.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=37557_MPlayer_OSX_Extended80cranSnapz004_122_520lo.jpg
http://img260.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=37558_MPlayer_OSX_Extended96cranSnapz003_122_341lo.jpg
http://img245.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=37559_MPlayer_OSX_Extended15cranSnapz002_122_491lo.jpg
Matt Hughes...impressive flaccid. How big does it get?
Based on the CFNM video, I'll give him between 8 7/16" and 9"... at his best.
I'm guessing his cock head is around 2". In the still frame I choose, the cock is not at 90 degrees. It might not be the best erection. In my 'stacked heads', I might be giving some leeway, but that might help factor in the variable questions...If 2 1/16", that would be 9 9/32" at extreme high end.
Was it a full moon?
Did he take any L Arginine supplements?
In the video she's promised 12 inches. She should have had a ruler handy.
Is there anything for James Deen yet?
The screen on movie 3 is a start, but not good enough to be decent evidence I guess. Maybe an estimation.
The clip is of something different when you download it too.
Milfs Like It Big