Chapter 3:
Part 1
I was awakened in the morning by my assistant. I looked at my phone, to see it was 9:30am as Teresa called to inform me, she had landed in NYC and was headed my way. I asked Teresa to come help me organize the selling of my parents house. She will be the one, hiring the contractors, seeing what we can sell or what needs to be tossed and working with the real estate agent on putting the house on the market.
Once Teresa arrived, we walked the house as she was taking notes. I grew up in a 5 bedroom colonial house, with 4 bathrooms, a pool in the backyard and a hot tub off the porch. I said my goodbye, as Teresa was headed to the fanciest hotel/spa in the county that I had booked. An hour later, I was leaving one of the only two coffee shops in the town center. Pennington has very strict laws, as all establishments are mom and pop owned.
I realized I hadn’t worked out in 3 days, so I decided to go to the town's only gym, which is adjusted to the golf course. As I opened the doors to Penn’s Fitness and looked up, I froze, I was horrified at who I saw! Standing behind the counter, was Tyler Worthington, my high school bully, who outed me my senior year in high school. My body instantly started to tremble and almost collapsed to the floor. A flood of horrible memories came rushing into my mind. As I was stepping backwards, looking to leave as fast as I could, Tyler looked up and saw me.
“Is that you Dunkie Finster? HOLY SHIT! It's been forever!” Tyler said as he ran over to greet me.
“I am so sorry about your parents. Your parents were such a pillar to the community! Especially your mother, the library wouldn’t be the same!” Tyler said, as he hugged me.
I stood there, as this fuckin asshole, who tormented me thoughout my teens, was now hugging me. He let go of me as I was still in shock. However, you always hear of the popular students who always peak at high school and typically become ugly, or fat as they get older. Not Tyler, the prick got even hotter!
Tyler’s family was one of the wealthiest in town. Standing at 6’5, about 225 lbs, sparkling hazel eyes and brownish blonde hair. He legit looks like he could be the identical twin of Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow. Tyler was wearing a tight Under Armour black t-shirt and tight black lululemon joggers. Fuck, his muscular arms, bulging pecs and his gorgeous tight firm ass, were getting me excited. I remember back in high school, word was, Tyler was hung. The asshole fucked anyone, from students, to teachers, to the alcoholic, pill popping, botox housewives.
“What are you doing here?” I stuttered.
“Well my dad bought this place almost 3 years ago and last year, he decided to move to Miami with his new young wife and left the place to me.” He said, while sporting his awarding winning dimples.
“What brings you here?” He asked.
“I am in town to take care of my parents house, before I put it on the market.” I said, while shaking like a little school girl meeting her crush.
After Tyler helped me set up my visitor pass while I was in town, I did my work order, which lasted almost 2 hours. I was really busy working the punching bag hard, taking out all my anger on Tyler when he stopped by to chat with me again.
“So, how have you been Dunkie? Can we talk, I need to get a few things off my chest.” Tyler said as he sat down on a weight lifting bench.
“Listen, I am truly sorry, from the bottom of my heart, how I treated you in high school. I was a stupid kid back then. I was very immature, trying to keep up this stupid status quo of being super popular and rich.
I was such an utter asshole for outing you during the Sadie Hawkins dance, in front of the whole school. I took that important moment away from you” Tyler said, as his head fell into his hands and started to cry.
I looked around the gym, thank god there weren’t many people around to see this. I was waiting for years to confront this piece of shit and get back at him somehow, however, at that moment, I simply sat next to him and pushed him in for a hug.
“I am very sorry Dunkie! You never have to forgive me for what I did to you. However, ever since my younger brother came out a few years ago and my father couldn't accept it nor his so-called “best friends”. I have been there for him ever since.” Tyler went on to say.
“Wait, you mean Paxton is gay!!?” I asked with a surprised look.
I remember Paxton extremely well! He was a freshman when I was a senior. He was groomed to be the next heir of the Worthington fortune and the next school legacy. The “It” boy. Holy shit, I thought to myself.
“Yeah, my father caught him messing around with his soccer teammate and beat the shit out of him and outed him and the kid to the whole school. The kid couldn’t handle it and ended up moving to another state and Paxton was pulled out of school and sent to some fancy boarding school in Europe.
It tore my family apart, my parents divorced and to this day, my father doesn't acknowledge him as his son. Ever since then, I have been by his side.” Tyler said, while wiping away tears from his face.
I was legit stunned by this, my enemy, the person I hated the most, I was now hugging him and embracing him as he told me this story. The next few words that came out of my mouth, stunned me, as I never thought I would say this.
“I forgive you Tyler. You were there for Paxton during a very hard time in his life. I hope he is doing well now.”
“He is a freshman at Columbia. It's his birthday tonight actually. Do you want to come out and celebrate it with us?” He asked, as he raised his face, showcasing his beautifull but puffy eyes and killer dimples.
As I was sitting in my rental, I banged my head against the steering wheel, still thinking WTF happened today. FUCKIN Tyler Worthington!!! Just then, I see a text coming from Daniel, informing me he wouldn’t be able to meet up with me tonight, but tomorrow he has no plans whatsoever. Just then, I did another stupid thing, I texted Tyler informing him I was down to go into the city to celebrate Paxton’s birthday.
A few hours later, I was standing in front of Suite, a gay lounge around Columbia, waiting for Tyler. I still couldn’t believe I was here, as I was leaning against a building, thinking how I would get my revenge towards this asshole. However, we are now older and wiser, so maybe forgiveness is the appropriate way to go. A few minutes later, I saw Tyler, Paxton and a few of his friends. As we walked in, I thought, maybe a little paycheck is still due.
The place was crowded with a mixture of younger college students and older sugar daddy types, probably trying to find their next sugar baby. I sat there, as I watched fuckin Tyler being Tyler, the center of attention. He was a hit at the bar, dancing with everyone, while they all bought him drinks. I sat there at the bar, sipping my martini and watching all of this. I ended up chatting with one of Paxtons friends and roomate, Roberto, who was from Spain.
After a few drinks and dancing on the dance floor, Roberto and I were in a bathroom stall, making out, while jacking one anothers cocks. Roberto was about 5’10, with olive skin, beautiful dark hair and gorgeous big brown eyes. He had this fat long uncut cock and a major bubble butt, that I couldn’t wait to fuck. As we were making out, I started to finger fuck his hole, getting him ready for me to fuck him, when I heard Roberto’s boyfriend come barging in and yanked him out of the stall and the bathroom.
As I walked out of the bathroom, with a massive hard on and blue balls, I saw Roberto and his tool of a boyfriend leave the bar. I went back to the bar, ordered a new drink, as I looked over at the thirsty men once again, as they had their hands all over Tyler, feeling his biceps and getting very close to him. As I was sipping my drink, I laughed to myself, as Tyler who was tipsy, was loving the attention and having everyone worshiping him.
After a while, Paxton was making out with one of the hot bartenders. As I continued sipping my drink, one of his thirsty friends came over to me. He introduced himself as Jameson and he was a cute 22 year black kid. He was about 6’1, skinny and kind of dorky.
“I see Paxton’s straight brother is a mega hit tonight!” I said, while finishing my drink and ordering a new one.
“The dude is hot and straight and we heard he is hung!” Jameson said, while stirring at Tyler.
Just as Jameson said that, something clicked in my head, as I noticed a few of the thirsty older men had Tyler arms wrapped around them. While watching this shit show, I strategize my payback plan towards Tyler! The douchebag was going to pay for all those years of hell he put me through. I went over to the bartenders, to ask them something.
“This is the best opportunity to get the crowd wild and buy more drinks. Having a super hot ex frat boy straight guy, becoming tonight's entertainment! Gays love straight hot go-go boys! Having him dancing in just his underwear will be a massive hit!” I said, with a delish grin, talking to the manager. He agreed, as he wanted to see Tyler in all his glory as well, now I just needed to convince the asshole.
I Pulled Tyler to the side, who was clearly tipsy. I had to “up” his super douche ego and convince him to strip and dance in front of some horny and thirsty gays. Ironocally, it wasn’t hard to convince him, as he said, “I love being naked, I was in a frat! We used to get naked all the time at parties!”.
A few minutes later, Taylor was coming out from the backroom, while the whole crowd was now hovering around the stage as the lights were being dimmed. I made sure Jameson was up front as I promised he would have the prize, Tyler. I volunteered as the MC and the DJ. However, before the main event could happen, I paid the bartender that was making out with Paxton, to take him home, to fuck him so he would not wittness what was going to happen to his brother.
I got on stage and told everyone to shut the fuck up, remember to tip your bartenders and introduced Tyler to the horny crowd. Everyone went wild when Tyler joined the stage, with a robe. The eagerness of thirst from Jameson and the crowd got me excited, I even noticed some bulges started to grow.
“Attention everyone! We have a special treat tonight for all your thirsty queens! Tonight, we have what I consider is one of the sexiest and hottest guys in the tri-state area!
Bonus points! HE IS STRAIGHT!! Let me introduce you to TYLER!” I said to the crowd, as roars of hungriness erupted.
As Tyler removed his robe and started to dance, the crowd went wild. Frat boys really are crazy mother fuckers! They love to party, drink and get naked. Watching as everyone was memorized by Tylers dancing in just his tight black Calvin Klein boxer brief trunks was polarizing. He had moves, not going to lie and knew his target audience and giving them the show they wanted. The fucker knew how to twerk and pop that booty, as the crowd loved it.
After fifteen minutes of Tyler dancing, I informed the crowd that we were going to take a break and to head to the bar, order drinks and to tip the bartenders well. Tyler said he had to use the bathroom and I informed Jamseson to wait a few seconds and then go to the bathroom, like he needed to pee. I then went in to check on Tyler.
“Dude, you are fantastic out there, the crowd really loves you. Didn’t know you have those kinds of moves.” I said
“Yea, when I attended Penn State and was in Beta Theta Pi fraternity and during our pledge, we had to strip at a gay bar. You know how fraternities are. Are you liking the show?” Tyler said, laughing with a grin.
Just then, Jameson walked in and went to the urinal.
“So, I was thinking, the next set, we take it up a notch, the crowd wants to see what you're packing?” I said to Tyler while passing him my weed vape.
“As long as they don’t touch me, I don’t mind showing everyone the goods, however, how am I going to get hard?” Tyler said as the weed was kicking in his eyes.
“I think I have a solution for that, keep puffing that vape. However, I just want to make sure you feel comfortable and everything is all consensual, as I gave Jameson the look.
I know someone that could help you with it, do you trust me?” I said.
Tyler nodded as the weed must have kicked in and with that Jameson came over to the sink. We all stood there for a few seconds of awkwardness, as I saw the sweat dripping down Tyler's body. In my mind, not going to lie, I wanted him to lift me up on the sink and fuck my brains out. Then, Jameson started to caress Tyler's body and feel his tight muscular ass. Tyler gave a WTF look and then, out of nowhere, the most shocking thing happened!
Tyler pushed me in and stuck his tongue down my throat, while his hands were planted on my cheeks. I pushed him away, shocked by what just happened. Jameson paused, as he was scared of what was going to happen next.
“Listen Dunkie, I haven’t been truthful regarding my intentions as to why I invited you here tonight. I meant what I said today at the gym, I am truly sorry for what I did to you back in high school. The thing is, with the help of Paxton, I realized I am attracted to guys. I am Bi.” Tyler said.
I legit almost fell to the ground, hearing this come out of Tyler's mouth, the poster boy of a WASPY male dominant, frat boy straight guy! My gaydar is always on point about a “straight” guy's sexuality, however this one caught me off guard. I snapped my fingers to Jameson to leave the bathroom.
“How drunk and high are you?” I asked.
“Dunkie, I always had these feelings for a long time, but was too ashamed to embrace them when I was younger, especially with my father and being the heir of the Worthington name. You remember what he did to Paxton.
The thing is, (as Tyler plopped himself on the sink), I was taking my anger out of being ashamed and confused, thinking something was wrong with me, on you, for being attracted to girls and guys.” Tyler said, looking straight at me.
“You fuckin ruined my teenage years asshole! You made my life a living hell! You bullied me throughout high school and outed me during the dance! I truly fucking hate you Tyler Worthington! You’re a piece of shit!” I angrily said, while pointing my finger at him.
Saying that out loud, felt like a huge weight was lifted off my chest. My therapist has always said this moment needed to happen. As we stirred deep into each other's eyes, standing there quietly for a few moments of silence, I got closer to him and placed my hands on his cheeks. Instead of punching him or slapping him, I leaned in and kissed him. You probably think I was crazy, or drunk, or high. However I wasn’t, even though I hated Tyler Worthington, I used to have a massive crush on him growing up. He was the reason I liked boys. I know, its weird, but after seeing him today at the gym and right at this moment, maybe my plan should be to have him fuck my brains out.
He wrapped his arms around me and we started to make out and I felt his cock twitching and getting hard in his underwear. Thinking in my mind, this trip back home has become extremely interesting. I pushed back and whispered into his ear, he needed to finish his second act and we could head back home. The crowd went wild during his second act, as Tyler was hard in his underwear and it made them even thirstier! Watching him dance, his hard cock pressing against the fabric of his tight underwear and the crowd going wild, made me super horny!
By the time we got back to my parents house in Pennington, I still couldn't believe what was going to happen. We ended up inviting Jameson as well, since I wanted to fuck this young stud. As I was in the kitchen, getting some beers from the fridge, Jameson came up to me. I don’t know what came over me. It was probably my horny male instinct that kicked in. I turned my head, leaned in, and brushed my nose up his face.
Jameson slammed me to the fridge and I found myself in the most intense passionate make out session of my life. Jameson lifted me up to the counter, as he spread my legs and started to lick and nibble on my neck, while pulling my shirt over my head and then biting and licking my hard sensitive nipples. The moans of passion came out of my mouth, as I bit my bottom lip, due to the sensations I was feeling.
I pulled my arms behind my head, leaning back, as Jameson kept licking my stomach, while grabbing my now hard cock and trying to unzip my pants. The fucker was good, as he pulled my pants down, while slowly licking my thighs and teasing my aching cock, that need to be released.
After a few minutes of being teased, I needed more. This young kid's tongue had teased me for far too long. I abruptly pushed him back and got off the counter, as we were looking each other square in the eye. The intensity of that gaze was electrifying. We both saw it in our eyes, hunger! With one quick motion, I ripped his T-shirt off, as we embraced one another, in a deep passionate kiss.
“I am going to fuck you!” I whispered into his ear, while nibbling on it.
Just then, we both looked at Tyler, I legit forgot he was here with us. I grabbed both of their hands and brought them to the bedroom. Tyler and I sat on the edge of the bed, as Jameson was hovering over us. He slowly lowered himself in front of me, as I leaned my head back and closed my eyes. Jameson moved his head towards my hard cock, as his lips hovered over my tip. He started to bob up and down, as I groaned loudly into the air. He took it as encouragement, sucking harder, swirling his tongue all over my cock and coating it in saliva.
"Holy shit! Fuck man, that feels great.” I yelled out, while my hands squeezed the sheets of the bed.
Jameson had a fuckin magic mouth. His tongue rolled around my cock, as he would occasionally lick my balls all the way to my taint. He kept doing this for probably about 20 minutes. As Jameson kept sucking my cock, I turned and saw Tyler looking at me, while stroking his fuckin enormous cock. I leaned in with my hand and started to stroke it, while we started to make out. Tyler would then whisper into my ear, “get rid of him!”.
I looked at him as he nodded his head, reconfirming to me to get rid of Jameson. Jameson sucked me off for like 10 minutes, as I was getting close. Before I knew it, I was on the edge of blowing my load.
"OH FUCK!!" I shouted, thrusting forward and grabbing his hair.
My cock erupted into his mouth. I shot loads and loads of creamy cum into his awaiting hungry mouth! My cum just kept flowing out and he swallowed it as fast as he could. After a few minutes of Jameson trying to swallow all my cum, I collapsed on the bed, sweating and out of breath. Jameson sat there, trying to regain his composure. During all this, Tyler informed the group Jameson’s Uber had arrived. I got up quickly, confused, as Tyler informed Jameson to get dressed and dragged home to the front door.