I quite enjoy sort of average not too fit bodies I've found most of the people who are crazy about them (fit guys and muscles) have actually never been with fit people and don't realise muscle isn't particularly comfortable in most intimate settings, not to mention the vast majority of guys dont keep it up for longer than a few years
Even chubby guys have a certain appeal sometimes
For dorky/nerdy guys like Scott he's perfect where he is, ties the whole look together and fits the fantasy, if people want muscly guys not sure why they would be looking at Scott or people like him barring a few exceptions