To give context on the options:
Pretty boy: it's all about a pretty face, usually a boyish look, kind of a twink but not necessarily, also can be any age (Matt Bomer is a pretty face at 44 years old) A male model with a slim body and pretty face fits here (Harry Styles, Timothee Chalamet, Jaden Smith, Korean Pop idols)
Fitness hunk: it's all about the body, gym bodies, big muscles, or being very fit (Chris Hemsworth, Dwayne Johnson "The Rock", Michael B. Jordan, most Instagram fitness models)
Dapper mature gent: A man who is classic handsome, manly, and confident, usually older than 40, but can be younger with a classic mature look. It's all about looking neat and elegant, think classic James Bond (John Hamm, Idris Elba, Benedict Cumberbatch, Henry Golding)
Rugged handsome: Very masculine, manly in an outdoorsy way, and even if good-looking, he is not "pretty", he is handsome, and sometimes with flaws. Probably has a beard or is hairy but not necessarily. He looks good but effortless, laidback, and casual (Jason Momoa, Gerard Butler, Joe Manganiello, Charlie Hunnam)
Alternative to hippie guy: Very broad category but is mostly about guys who have an edge, men who do not conform to typical masculine expectations or conventional aesthetics. Think of a lot of tattoos or piercings or long hair (straight, curly, or dreadlocks), or more gender-neutral clothing, or emos, hippies, punk, etc. (Post Malone, Johnny Depp, Lil Wayne, Jared Leto, most rock/punk/alternative musicians)
Average Joe: Just guys who are average-looking, they can be attractive but not in a very "mainstream" way, they even can be attractive just to you. Usually, they are not muscular or fit, mostly average, from skinny to "dad bods" to chubby. (Adam Sandler, Zach Braff, Mark Ruffalo, Michael Peña)
Pretty boy: it's all about a pretty face, usually a boyish look, kind of a twink but not necessarily, also can be any age (Matt Bomer is a pretty face at 44 years old) A male model with a slim body and pretty face fits here (Harry Styles, Timothee Chalamet, Jaden Smith, Korean Pop idols)
Fitness hunk: it's all about the body, gym bodies, big muscles, or being very fit (Chris Hemsworth, Dwayne Johnson "The Rock", Michael B. Jordan, most Instagram fitness models)
Dapper mature gent: A man who is classic handsome, manly, and confident, usually older than 40, but can be younger with a classic mature look. It's all about looking neat and elegant, think classic James Bond (John Hamm, Idris Elba, Benedict Cumberbatch, Henry Golding)
Rugged handsome: Very masculine, manly in an outdoorsy way, and even if good-looking, he is not "pretty", he is handsome, and sometimes with flaws. Probably has a beard or is hairy but not necessarily. He looks good but effortless, laidback, and casual (Jason Momoa, Gerard Butler, Joe Manganiello, Charlie Hunnam)
Alternative to hippie guy: Very broad category but is mostly about guys who have an edge, men who do not conform to typical masculine expectations or conventional aesthetics. Think of a lot of tattoos or piercings or long hair (straight, curly, or dreadlocks), or more gender-neutral clothing, or emos, hippies, punk, etc. (Post Malone, Johnny Depp, Lil Wayne, Jared Leto, most rock/punk/alternative musicians)
Average Joe: Just guys who are average-looking, they can be attractive but not in a very "mainstream" way, they even can be attractive just to you. Usually, they are not muscular or fit, mostly average, from skinny to "dad bods" to chubby. (Adam Sandler, Zach Braff, Mark Ruffalo, Michael Peña)