In order: dapper mature/ruggedly handsome, alternatitve, average joe/fitness hunk; top esthetic: handsomeness/strong features; major considerations: confidence (not to be confused with arrogance), mystery, presence.
I prefer mature/stronger features to the boyish look and physicality not on the extremes either in slimnness or stoutness, though lean a bit right of that center. Whereas I like fit men, it can become too much for me really quickly. "Dad bods" can be hot; in fact, I prefer Chris Pratt in "Dad Bod" mode. I have found several chubbier/chubby guys attractive - possibly influenced by my being slim/thin most of my life until more recently, usually of the mature variation, often of an ethnicity with a more machismo culture (Greek, Arab, etc.), with a decent amount of body hair. Only more recently have I found any fitting the "twink" look attractive, and that is still hard to come by. But ultimately, body type, weight, look aside, an extremely important factor to the type of men I find attractive is how they carry themselves and their confidence, which is ultimately why dapper mature/rugged handsome men start and end at the front for me.