I think not. It was something like the "Erotica" on 8th Ave around 44th st, maybe, tho I can't recall exactly. Know what was weird? There were about 8 guys in the contest. The only fit ones were me and this other guy, a nice-looking dude who told me he was Puerto Rican.
Each man took his turn on the small stage. I had decided with a kind of preppy polo shirt and thin white briefs, not quite bikini briefs, which I didn't like, but a little skimpier than, say, tighty whities. This was 1984 and I was 24 yrs old.
I remember getting up on stage, thrilled with the illicitness of it all, and popping my preppy collared admiring myself in the full wall mirror at the back of the stage, kind of groping myself for their enjoyment.
I did some kind of lame-ass dance step and then came the "wet" in the wet underwear dept: The audience were given SQUIRT GUNS! And they weren't filled with warm water, lemme tell ya! So as I "Danced" in my briefs, the guys squirted me with water so that my underwear became wet and they could see the outline of my semi-erect cock and my pouched balls. Tho' the entire "performance" was very sexy to me, that feeling was attenuated a good deal by the utter silliness of grown men squirting a dancer with water pistols.
I finished my little dance without getting fully hard. At the end of the evening, all 8 guys came back on stage (incl one older man in red flannel, open-back hillbilly long underwear (I remember thinking, "Who thinks THAT is hot??). Each of us stepped forward and the "emcee" gauged the popularity of each dancer with a VERY precisely calibrated "Applause-O-Meter." In other words, he just estimated the duration and volume of the applause. I ended up winning and my Puerto Rican buddy got second. This means I earned, I dunno, maybe $25 (plus the thrill of winning) and he got nothing. I seem to recall that as we were getting dressed, he made a comment about his disappointment. I had the feeling that that money would have bade a BIG difference to him, and I remembering thinking I should offer to split it. I can't now recall if I actually DID offer. I have a memory of us leaving together and walking toward Port Authority Bus Station. I may have offered it then, but he declined.
As with all these things, I wish I could magically locate this guy from 40 years ago and hear about his life.