Amandla ? She’s mixed. Dad is white and her Mom is black. She doesn’t have lighter skin than you lol.

hell, if you want to get technical, even I’m mixed. We all came from Africa, right?

nonetheless, I’m sure even your constituents who normally agree with you would disagree with your statement that skin color is so cut and dry. Skin tones definitely overlap between all races.
 
Looks like we are talking with someone that tells that races don't exist, but act like they do and he has his own idea about what races are, lol.


Oh my... Melanin is augmented by UV, not temperature. That's quite a basic knowledge. Or it should be lol.
If that wasn't enough, yep, southern europe can be warmer than some part of Africa.
You really need to understand that races doesn't exist, and your are just bias based on prejudice.

:joy: Lord have mercy ! Seems to me that you don’t understand the geographical landscape of which you’re trying to argue. Melanin generation is augmented by UV rays that’s correct. But you are aware that UV rays are stronger below the equator correct ? More UV penetration to earth increases the temperature. Races are a social construct created by human beings. It won’t stop being a thing until society determines otherwise. If you’re going to debate with me. I ask that you know what you’re talking about. Thanks !
 
  • Like
Reactions: deleted15807
hell, if you want to get technical, even I’m mixed. We all came from Africa, right?

nonetheless, I’m sure even your constituents who normally agree with you would disagree with your statement that skin color is so cut and dry. Skin tones definitely overlap between all races.

Yeah, you’re right about. You are technically mixed. Skin tone can vary and somewhat overlap, but that doesn’t range into white people having dark skin though.
 
View attachment 31095301

What race is this woman? She has lighter skin than me. Lol. And she’s not even the lightest skinned of black people ive seen.
Man, I think that this Nigel guy is actually a troll and a racist
:joy: Lord have mercy ! Seems to me that you don’t understand the geographical landscape of which you’re trying to argue. Melanin generation is augmented by UV rays that’s correct. But you are aware that UV rays are stronger below the equator correct ? More UV penetration to earth increases the temperature. Races are a social construct created by human beings. It won’t stop being a thing until society determines otherwise. If you’re going to debate with me. I ask that you know what you’re talking about. Thanks !
:joy: Lord have mercy ! Seems to me that you don’t understand the geographical landscape of which you’re trying to argue. Melanin generation is augmented by UV rays that’s correct. But you are aware that UV rays are stronger below the equator correct ? More UV penetration to earth increases the temperature. Races are a social construct created by human beings. It won’t stop being a thing until society determines otherwise. If you’re going to debate with me. I ask that you know what you’re talking about. Thanks !
You don't understand basic geography, talking like Africa was big as a Walmart.
Tyipical "first world" mentality, lol.
I litterally live in southern Europe, in a multiethnic city, and not only I studied genetics at medical university, but I have also the empiric proofs.
What you call "white people" don't exist, you need to understand that. You keep saying that races are a construct, but you are the one that actually talk as races existed.
 
Yeah, you’re right about. You are technically mixed. Skin tone can vary and somewhat overlap, but that doesn’t range into white people having dark skin though.
And this is the comment of someone that still believe in races.
 
Man, I think that this Nigel guy is actually a troll and a racist


You don't understand basic geography, talking like Africa was big as a Walmart.
Tyipical "first world" mentality, lol.
I litterally live in southern Europe, in a multiethnic city, and not only I studied genetics at medical university, but I have also the empiric proofs.
What you call "white people" don't exist, you need to understand that. You keep saying that races are a construct, but you are the one that actually talk as races existed.

Do you understand what racist means ? :joy: I’m going also going to go out limp and state that English isn’t your first language. Because you clearly don’t understand. When did I suggest that Africa was the size of a Walmart ? Africa is one of the largest Continents. Doesn’t erase the fact that it’s below the equator. In all those university studies, you didn’t learn that ? What part of social construct didn’t you understand. Technically races aren’t a thing yes, but by society standards they do and that what my statement is based on. If you don’t understand that then I can’t help you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: deleted15807
Do you understand what racist means ? :joy: I’m going also going to go out limp and state that English isn’t your first language. Because you clearly don’t understand. When did I suggest that Africa was the size of a Walmart ? Africa is one of the largest Continents. Doesn’t erase the fact that it’s below the equator. In all those university studies, you didn’t learn that ? What part of social construct didn’t you understand. Technically races aren’t a thing yes, but by society standards they do and that what my statement is based on. If you don’t understand that then I can’t help you.
Oh, it's just something that leaks from everything you type.
Clearly you just wanted to pic an argument with that guy, but your true self showed up.
For example with that "mixed" you said about him, right after you told me that races are just a construct.
Oh, the hypocrisy :D
Please stop spreading that nonsense about who is white and who is black. It's so... Colonialist, Nigel.
 
Do you understand what racist means ? :joy: I’m going also going to go out limp and state that English isn’t your first language. Because you clearly don’t understand. When did I suggest that Africa was the size of a Walmart ? Africa is one of the largest Continents. Doesn’t erase the fact that it’s below the equator. In all those university studies, you didn’t learn that ? What part of social construct didn’t you understand. Technically races aren’t a thing yes, but by society standards they do and that what my statement is based on. If you don’t understand that then I can’t help you.
Btw saying that Africa is below the equator made me laugh. It has more area above it. Did you check a map, recently? Or checked the average temperature of Africa compared to southern Europe?
And what about the non central parte of Africa?
Again, that's a continent, son, not a mall.
 
Oh, it's just something that leaks from everything you type.
Clearly you just wanted to pic an argument with that guy, but your true self showed up.
For example with that "mixed" you said about him, right after you told me that races are just a construct.
Oh, the hypocrisy :D
Please stop spreading that nonsense about who is white and who is black. It's so... Colonialist, Nigel.

:joy: Unintelligible nonsense. You have no clue what racist means. Got it. Do you even know who that was in that photo Ark attached ? Her name is amandla stenberg. She’s an actress. One of the roles she best known from is Rue from the hunger games movie franchise. She is mixed. :joy: Her father is white and mother is black. I wouldn’t go repeating that races isn’t a thing outside of the internet. You’re going to get laughed at. Stop being dense.
 
Btw saying that Africa is below the equator made me laugh. It has more area above it. Did you check a map, recently? Or checked the average temperature of Africa compared to southern Europe?
And what about the non central parte of Africa?
Again, that's a continent, son, not a mall.

This is getting downright embarrassing now. :joy: I had no clue you were simple minded. Africa is below the equator. There is only a small part of North Africa that is above it. Go check a map friend. Please never speak on Africa again until you learn properly about it. This is sad.
 
When people say race is a social construct, I usually reply by saying “everything is a social construct!”

Just because something is a social construct, doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist!
 
When people say race is a social construct, I usually reply by saying “everything is a social construct!”

Just because something is a social construct, doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist!

....a social construct means it only exist as defined by some subjective measure but it has no biological meaning. Race is meaningless and useless as a concept. We no longer use it in science.
 
....a social construct means it only exist as defined by some subjective measure but it has no biological meaning. Race is meaningless and useless as a concept. We no longer use it in science.

Money is a social construct. (It’s paper that we give value to)

Intelligence is a social. (Intelligence in a modern sense is entirely constructed on invented measures.)

The family unit is a social construct.

Gender roles are a social construct.

Law is a social construct (who inventes them and are they just?)

Society is a social construct.

Culture is a social construct.

Literacy is a social construct (in linguistics, literacy is hard to define)

The economy (capitalism, socialism, communism, etc.) is a social construct.

All these things are social constructs, having no real basis in nature other than the basis we apply to them. However, all of these things are very real and we have to live with it. Genetics, phenotypes, and traits are real!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Duq2016
....a social construct means it only exist as defined by some subjective measure but it has no biological meaning. Race is meaningless and useless as a concept. We no longer use it in science.

we no longer use it in science because too many people have deemed it an unethical subject matter. Not because it was meaningless.

biologists used to use words such as “negroloids”, and “mongoloids” when classifying humans. Those words are no longer used for obvious reasons. People considered such classifications dehumanizing.

a lot of people also don’t like that fact that we are “animals”... which, we are. Just because we have true sentience, and can perform “high level thinking,” humans give themselves more value than other life forms. A life form more advanced than us wouldn’t really think more of us than we think of say... worms, or ants.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
we no longer use it in science because too many people have deemed it an unethical subject matter.
.

No. We dont use it in genetics because it is meaningless. Human population cant be categorically divided like that in such arbitrary terms. You have said it yourself, skin tone varies, hair color varies etc.

The terms in use now are ethnicity and ancestry. With these terms, the variations are tied to actual genetic markers. Race is meaningless and will become even more meaningless as people from different ethnic groups marry. Look at Obama. Was he White or Black? Genetically he was equally black and white. What race is a Hispanic person? We are a blend of all 3 races. How useful is it to know your race when there is so much variation within that race? Imagine this: A black person from Somalia belongs to the same race as a black person from Memphis Tennessee. Do you really think that two ppl from such disparate ethnic group will share that many genetic markers just because they have the same skin color and maybe eye color and hair type?

In general, race has very limited use outside of anthropology. And even that is arguable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: deleted5199391
No. We dont use it in genetics because it is meaningless. Human population cant be categorically divided like that in such arbitrary terms. You have said it yourself, skin tone varies, hair color varies etc.

genetics encompasses a study of how closely related organisms are to one another. We can look at genetics of people from
Different races, and trace back the lineage to the point where their ancestors branched off long ago.

yes, our ancestors separated, branched off, and were isolated from each other for a long period of time, allowing them to differentiate... certainly not to the point where we became different species from one another (as we all have incredibly similar DNA, and are still closely related), but enough for phenotypical difference to arise.

now that our species has become global co-minglers, our differentiation has stopped, and in thousands... or even tens of thousands of years... our progeny will all look more or less the same.
 
Money is a social construct. (It’s paper that we give value to)

Intelligence is a social. (Intelligence in a modern sense is entirely constructed on invented measures.)

The family unit is a social construct.

Gender roles are a social construct.

Law is a social construct (who inventes them and are they just?)

Society is a social construct.

Culture is a social construct.

Literacy is a social construct (in linguistics, literacy is hard to define)

The economy (capitalism, socialism, communism, etc.) is a social construct.

All these things are social constructs, having no real basis in nature other than the basis we apply to them. However, all of these things are very real and we have to live with it. Genetics, phenotypes, and traits are real!

See my response above.
 
genetics encompasses a study of how closely related organisms are to one another. We can look at genetics of people from
Different races, and trace back the lineage to the point where their ancestors branched off long ago.

yes, our ancestors separated, branched off, and were isolated from each other for a long period of time, allowing them to differentiate... certainly not to the point where we became different species from one another (as we all have incredibly similar DNA, and are still closely related), but enough for phenotypical difference to arise.

now that our species has become global co-minglers, our differentiation has stopped, and in thousands... or even tens of thousands of years... our progeny will all look more or less the same.

Thats precisely the problem. I need to see if I can link the article here but basically when scientist tried to use race as a proxy for ancestry it didnt work. Someone from Korea could look more closely related to someone from Europe than someone from Europe to someone from another European country (both white). This is especially true for the White "race". I think White and Black are the most problematic. I will try to explain in anotherbpost. Cell is dying.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fishsqueezee69