Mandingo clearly has 10, but that is another debate.
Rob Piper is not fully erect in the measurement as you have admitted. The bottom line is at 8". His penis is longer than 8 in the measurement, you can see his glans are well over the 8. So why would his dick magically shrink to 7.5 on a top measurement, if he is measured over 8 not fully erect? The reasoning is just flawed. Dicks do not shrink this way. Your saying he will lose about 1.5 inches if he measures on top correctly, it makes no sense. If Rob Piper measured on top, I have no doubt he would 8.75.
View attachment 1635093
I noticed sdp rated your comment up, everyone here says he is 8.5 NBP but he looks smaller than Rob Piper. I can't keep feeling that this thread is just used to bash pornstars and for people to feel good about their own dicks.
I don't personally dont buy into the dildo argument, but as users here are obsessed with claiming the insertable length is undeniably the penis size of a pornstar
Rob Piper has a 10.5 inch dildo with a 8.5 inch insertable
Doc Johnson Rob Piper UltraSkyn Cock - Large realistic brown dildo
The 8.5 is closer to my estimate of 8.75 than the 7.5 claim on here.
You are reverting to your old ways.
I agree there are people who downplay I was banned due to fighting with them before lol.
But you are using the same lack of deductive reasoning in the opposite direction with some of your claims.
The evidence shows what the evidence shows regardless of people's psychological motivations.
Maybe some guys do downplay for insecure or jealous reasons. But maybe you "overplay " For your own reasons. Maybe it is a reaction against the guys with very low claims and you are going too far the other way. The point being we can only speculate whether or not someone is biased and what their motivation is.
Doesn't change the fact some of your guesses are contrary to the evidence. Mandingo can't be 10 there is 0 per cent chance he is 10 or even 9.5nbp
9 is fair. He was measured fully hard at a very downward angle in relation to the doll. Everyone agrees the measure shows 9.5 it is obvious he would be around 9 measured properly.
Shane Diesel is 7.5. There is not just a dildo but a McDonald's cup measurement that corroborated that.
Slim poke can't be 9. Of course if you think Mandingo is 10 I guess he could.
It is obvious just by looking Mandingo is the biggest in porn and Gomez and Dredd are next. Then Lex and Danny D and Vlad, Richard Mann etx. In terms of length only the first 3 are 8.5+.
So we can tell just by looking that many of these guys aren't 8.5+
That might not sound empirical but it's like if you saw a 6 foot man you could just tell he ain't 6 5. You wouldn't need to see them next to each other .
In the same way it is obvious Rod Piper isn't 8.5 to me.
In that picture it is the same like the Mandingo measured pic. Downward angle like that and you really do gain like 0.5 to 0.75 inches compared to parallel. A lot of the bigger guys have downward angled dicks when not held up. I'm not saying he's fully hard there but he isn't far from it regardless of the angle.
It's not jealousy personally I'm more impressed by girth anyway.
