For some background, I had two friends I had known for years. We hung out all the time. Us three, a few more, a few less. We were all friends. I invited (let’s call him) Gavin and Mark over to hangout. Gavin has always been the athletic one - super fit, tan, played lots of sports, but always seemed a little questionable. He had a girlfriend of 4 months, I always figured he was straight because he would always willingly admit to me what they’d do together. Gavin was the type of guy who was straight but would smack other guys’ asses, poke and prod every now and then, but never suspected to be gay. Mark had never dated anyone, he was on the heavier side, super friendly and funny. Definitely straight. Mark and Gavin came over to my house after we grabbed some pizza at a local restaurant. We were in my bedroom and I said “let’s play truth or dare!”. We played casually, nothing crazy, there were no crazy dares or questions until Gavin said something I never expected.
“I dare you to whip it out.”, said Gavin.
I was completely shook, I didn’t know how to respond. I had never considered myself gay but was always pretty curious.
I said in response, “Ew Gavin.. Not here. Not with the door wide open and with other people home. And plus, I’m not gay.”
Gavin said, “You’re such a pussy. Fine.”
I secretly hoped he would push to ask again, but I didn’t want to seem too ‘gay’ so I didn’t mention it. The game went on and we just kept playing, asking more riskier questions. Gavin and I kept making up dares and asking questions (that neither of us did or answered) that were definitely pretty gay. Mark was clearly uncomfortable.
Gavin said, “Mark, if you want to play spicy truth or dare, come with us into the closet. If not, stay out here and do whatever.”
“I don’t know what you guys are doing but I just wanna watch this video on YouTube. Do whatever.”, said Mark.
Gavin and I went through bathroom and into my closet. I had a huge closet, so this wasn’t a big deal - it was easily big enough to fit 5 people. We shut the door.
Gavin said, “Ok. Now that it’s just us. Let’s play spicy truth or dare.”
I said, “Ok.. I don’t know what that means. I’m so bored though.”
Gavin said, “I dare you to whip it out. I dared you to do it before, now you have to do it now.”
I, hesitantly, said, “Ok. Fine. I will.”
Gavin was visibly shocked. I don’t think he was expecting me to agree. I unbuttoned my jeans, pulled them down a little, and grabbed my cock from out of my underwear. Gavin’s face lit up. I could tell he was interested. He kept saying “It’s so big. It’s so big. What the fuck.”. We kinda stopped playing truth or dare and I just said, “now it’s your turn. Pull your dick out. Let’s measure.” Gavin didn’t hesitate, he pulled it out of his shorts. His dick was a bit smaller than mine. Still a decent size. We were both cut. I pulled out a ruler I just so happened to have in my closet and we both measured our dicks right next to eachother. After that, he grabbed my dick. Just lightly. He said “I dare you to have a sword fight with me.” without responding, he and I started to have a ‘sword fight’ with our dicks. We were both rock hard. After that, we both just had our dicks hanging out of our shorts. Standing there…. awkwardly in the closet.
Gavin said, “Screw truth or dare. I’ll do whatever you want. I’m so bored.”
I was pretty confused. I had no idea what he meant by that. I just said, “what does ‘whatever I want’ mean?”.
Gavin responded with “What. Ever. You. Want. I’ll do anything.”
I kinda jokingly said, “Ok then get on your knees and suck my dick.”
He said, “This won’t be the first time I have sucked a dick. I’ll gladly do that.”
I’m sure my face turned bright red. I was so confused. I felt a little betrayed he never told me anything and turned on at the same time.
—— To be continued….
“I dare you to whip it out.”, said Gavin.
I was completely shook, I didn’t know how to respond. I had never considered myself gay but was always pretty curious.
I said in response, “Ew Gavin.. Not here. Not with the door wide open and with other people home. And plus, I’m not gay.”
Gavin said, “You’re such a pussy. Fine.”
I secretly hoped he would push to ask again, but I didn’t want to seem too ‘gay’ so I didn’t mention it. The game went on and we just kept playing, asking more riskier questions. Gavin and I kept making up dares and asking questions (that neither of us did or answered) that were definitely pretty gay. Mark was clearly uncomfortable.
Gavin said, “Mark, if you want to play spicy truth or dare, come with us into the closet. If not, stay out here and do whatever.”
“I don’t know what you guys are doing but I just wanna watch this video on YouTube. Do whatever.”, said Mark.
Gavin and I went through bathroom and into my closet. I had a huge closet, so this wasn’t a big deal - it was easily big enough to fit 5 people. We shut the door.
Gavin said, “Ok. Now that it’s just us. Let’s play spicy truth or dare.”
I said, “Ok.. I don’t know what that means. I’m so bored though.”
Gavin said, “I dare you to whip it out. I dared you to do it before, now you have to do it now.”
I, hesitantly, said, “Ok. Fine. I will.”
Gavin was visibly shocked. I don’t think he was expecting me to agree. I unbuttoned my jeans, pulled them down a little, and grabbed my cock from out of my underwear. Gavin’s face lit up. I could tell he was interested. He kept saying “It’s so big. It’s so big. What the fuck.”. We kinda stopped playing truth or dare and I just said, “now it’s your turn. Pull your dick out. Let’s measure.” Gavin didn’t hesitate, he pulled it out of his shorts. His dick was a bit smaller than mine. Still a decent size. We were both cut. I pulled out a ruler I just so happened to have in my closet and we both measured our dicks right next to eachother. After that, he grabbed my dick. Just lightly. He said “I dare you to have a sword fight with me.” without responding, he and I started to have a ‘sword fight’ with our dicks. We were both rock hard. After that, we both just had our dicks hanging out of our shorts. Standing there…. awkwardly in the closet.
Gavin said, “Screw truth or dare. I’ll do whatever you want. I’m so bored.”
I was pretty confused. I had no idea what he meant by that. I just said, “what does ‘whatever I want’ mean?”.
Gavin responded with “What. Ever. You. Want. I’ll do anything.”
I kinda jokingly said, “Ok then get on your knees and suck my dick.”
He said, “This won’t be the first time I have sucked a dick. I’ll gladly do that.”
I’m sure my face turned bright red. I was so confused. I felt a little betrayed he never told me anything and turned on at the same time.
—— To be continued….
