This thread has been on my mind since OP (hi Zackattack!) posted, and I have thoughts that I have been curated all week, trying to somehow categorize, and also amending because others have already identified them.
I'm going to get these big names out of the way, because they are my all-time SC favs, and I will never get enough of them:
Ross, Dylan, Patrick, Brooks, Peter
And I will echo everyone else who has been mentioned by other posters, and will amplify the appreciation shown for
Russ, Jonathan, Cooper, Brooks
My ranking is in more-or-less chronological order., and I've tried my best with links and photos
Part I: The Ones Who Should Have Come Back for More
Isaak (2003): from the early days of SC, this lean, dark, curly-haired cutie allowed himself to be blown by Sean himself, and went on to expand his boundaries with the contemporary powerhouses of the day like Trevor and
Zack... I also loved his role in
Fuckfest 3, and how vocal he always was.
View attachment 169180061
Jamie: cute-as-a-button, freshly 18 y/o Asian boy ("I'm 18 and a half!") with a defined chest, a bubble butt, and the fairest skin... I had the biggest crush on him back in the day, and the fact that he didn't come back to get that bubble butt penetrated is one of my most frustrating "what ifs".
View attachment 169180701
Curtis (I): overshadowed by his much more prolific red-headed gay power bottom, this buff Keanu Reeves-lookalike went on to get
blown by Patrick... I'm still furious that we didn't get to see more of him.
View attachment 169183761
View attachment 169184791
Tucker: (see also Curtis I above) this spiky-haired stud-next-door with the smoldering dark and handsome good looks had a body and cock that begged to be worshipped, as evidenced by his episode where he gets rimmed and
blown/rimmed by contemporary SC MVP Jeffrey (more on him another time). I don't know how Jeffrey held back, because I would've coaxed Tucker into taking it!
View attachment 169183081
View attachment 169184421
Topher: Curly-haired sandy brunette, with a solid jaw, and a tight body gave a finance-bro type, this self-proclaimed straight stud ended up
getting blown by beefy Barry, skipped the "I'm a straight guy who can only top", and
went straight to taking it from beefcake Mitch (and looked beautiful while doing it on camera for the first time, and in the outtakes, seemed satisfactorily confused at how good it felt)
View attachment 169182411
View attachment 169183061
[
much more to come!]