Sorry I missed this.
I want to start by saying that I do indeed have a bleak view on relationships, not because I think relationships themselves are bad, but when I speak to people who are in them or have had them, it really makes me wonder. As I lack the personal experience, I rely on other people's testimonials, and over the years I've accumulated similar trends.
This is not to say *every* relationship is bad/doomed - I met several happy couples. What I noticed is they met years ago, or were in school etc together often, i.e. didn't meet through the current 'dating world' we face today. My thread was more about the world we are in now, sorry, I should have clarified this.
In terms of judgement and appearance, I would also say, generally, I think its become more extreme overall. For example, l bodybuilding used to be quite a niche sport. When I started in the gym only a few guys even were trying to add muscle. As I have gotten older, it seems like every other guy is on this path. Therefore the beauty standards have sky rocketed somewhat. Interestingly, I never actually based 'dating' on someones body, as I've always been more a "face" person. Therefore I've never been interested or attracted to "Instagram" types or even chase after them. I honestly thought I would come out, find a nice guy, be married and that would be it. Clearly I was wrong.
Indeed, all relationships are hard work, and I guess my post was trying to think for myself what kind of guy would I want to put the hard work into now (vs in my 20s). As time has gone by, and I've remained single, my "needs" have decreased because I'm basically taken care of myself, and it was more a self-analysis vs a criticism.
I think your last paragraph is spot on in terms of how I feel and better phrased than I think I articulated.